News | April 11, 2007

More than Half of All Programs Provide Financial Incentives for Better Quality Care, Survey Says

April 12, 2007 - In the first published nationwide survey of state Medicaid programs on "pay-for-performance" practices, more than half of all programs state that they provide financial incentives to health care providers for better quality care. Almost 85 percent of states plan to have pay-for-performance programs within five years. Researchers also found that most current programs focus on women's, children's and adolescents' health issues. The study is published today by The Commonwealth Fund, a private foundation working toward a high-performance health system. Authors are from IPRO, a not-for-profit quality evaluation and improvement organization and The Kuhmerker Consulting Group, LLC, a health care consulting firm.

"Medicaid is a major source of funding of health care in every state and, therefore, has a significant influence on the health care system," said Thomas Hartman, Vice President for Health Care Quality Improvement for IPRO and co- author of the study. "But each state operates its program independently of the others. We thought it would be helpful to provide a detailed snapshot of what is taking place around the nation so that state officials have solid information on which to base decisions about pay-for-performance."

Hartman and co-author Kathryn Kuhmerker, President of the Kuhmerker Group and former Medicaid Director for New York State, found several trends. Nine Medicaid programs (Arizona, Kansas, Maine, Minnesota, New Hampshire, New York, Oregon, Vermont, and Washington) are joining in statewide and regional pay- for-performance and quality improvement efforts, and others are considering entering into such collaborations. Health information technology is a focus of numerous Medicaid pay-for-performance programs (Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Massachusetts,
Minnesota, New York, Pennsylvania, and Utah). In these programs, providers are given incentives to adopt electronic health records and electronic prescribing, often in conjunction with the collaborative efforts described above. Access to care is a continuing concern of state Medicaid directors, and that concern is reflected in the approaches they take in this area. An overwhelming majority of Medicaid directors state that their pay-for-performance priority is on improving quality, not on reducing cost.

"Medicaid is not a new entrant into the field of pay-for-performance," according to Kuhmerker. "We learned that almost half of all programs, in fact, are more than five years old." More than 70 percent of planned new programs are expected to start in the next two years.

"The effort to link health care spending and quality is a growing phenomenon in the health care industry," said Karen Davis, President, The Commonwealth Fund. "Both quality and efficiency are key components of a high performance health system, and it is encouraging to see the states rewarding provider efforts in these areas."

The study found that 70 percent of existing Medicaid pay-for-performance programs operate in managed care or primary care case management (PCCM) environments, with a focus on preventive health services and children's, adolescents' and women's health issues.

"New programs are still focused mainly on managed care and PCCM providers," Kuhmerker said, "but appear to be shifting their emphasis to the quality and cost issues related to chronic diseases like asthma and diabetes."

Hartman and Kuhmerker gathered information through a written survey sent to all state Medicaid directors, conducted follow-up interviews with the directors and their staffs, and reviewed a range of documents and Web-based resources on the programs. The study focused on programs that provide financial rewards for quality, efficiency and other program attributes. The study was conducted from May through October 2006.

"Very few states have conducted formal evaluations of their pay-for- performance programs, but most Medicaid officials believe that the overall quality of care being provided is improving as a result of these programs," said Hartman. "More research clearly needs to be done to assess the effects of pay-for-performance on the quality of care provided to Medicaid recipients."

To view a copy of the study, please go to http://www.cmwf.org or http://www.ipro.org.

Related Content

ClearRead CT Nearing 50 Installations Milestone
News | Computed Tomography (CT) | June 22, 2017
June 22, 2017 — Riverain Technologies announced that it is now processing data from nearly 50...
Carestream Spotlights New Imaging Analytics Tools for Preventative Care at SIIM 2017, Clinical Collaboration Platform
News | Computer-Aided Detection Software | May 15, 2017
Carestream Health is demonstrating new imaging analytics tools that are being added to its Clinical Collaboration...
Low-Cost AI Could Screen for Cervical Cancer Better Than Humans
Feature | Artificial Intelligence | April 25, 2017
Artificial intelligence (AI) is already exceeding human abilities. Self-driving cars use AI to perform some tasks more...
Parascript and Volpara Establish Partnership for Improved Early Cancer Detection
News | Computer-Aided Detection Software | April 11, 2017
Parascript LLC announced a new partnership with Volpara Solutions, creator of Volpara Density automated breast density...
iCAD, PowerLook Tomo Detection, computer-aided detection software, CAD, digital breast tomosynthesis, DBT, RSNA 2017
Technology | Computer-Aided Detection Software | March 27, 2017
March 27, 2017 — iCAD announced that PowerLook Tomo Detection received Premarket Approval (PMA) from the U.S.
Parascript, AccuDetect CAD for Mammography, computer-aided detection, NCoBC 2017
News | Computer-Aided Detection Software | March 15, 2017
Parascript will exhibit at the National Consortium of Breast Centers (NCoBC) 27th Conference, March 11-17, 2017, in Las...
artificial intelligence, radiology, five reasons, Signify Research report
News | Artificial Intelligence | December 19, 2016
December 19, 2016 — A recent report from market research firm Signify Research presents five reasons why...
Sponsored Content | Videos | Artificial Intelligence | December 16, 2016
At RSNA 2016, the key buzzwords were “deep learning,” “machine learning” and “artificial intelligence.” Vendors and m
Sponsored Content | Videos | Artificial Intelligence | December 08, 2016
Mark Michalski, M.D., director of the Center for Clinical Data Science at Massachusetts General Hospital, explains th
Technology | Computer-Aided Detection Software | December 07, 2016
QView Medical Inc. announced that it received U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval in early November for...
Overlay Init