News | Artificial Intelligence | August 07, 2023

Scientists design new way to score accuracy of AI-generated radiology reports 

Scientists design new way to score accuracy of AI-generated radiology reports 

August 7, 2023 — AI tools that quickly and accurately create detailed narrative reports of a patient’s CT scan or X-ray can greatly ease the workload of busy radiologists. 

Instead of merely identifying the presence or absence of abnormalities on an image, these AI reports convey complex diagnostic information, detailed descriptions, nuanced findings, and appropriate degrees of uncertainty. In short, they mirror how human radiologists describe what they see on a scan. 

Several AI models capable of generating detailed narrative reports have begun to appear on the scene. With them have come automated scoring systems that periodically assess these tools to help inform their development and augment their performance. 

So how well do the current systems gauge an AI model’s radiology performance? 

The answer is good but not great, according to a new study by researchers at Harvard Medical School published Aug. 3 in the journal Patterns

Ensuring that scoring systems are reliable is critical for AI tools to continue to improve and for clinicians to trust them, the researchers said, but the metrics tested in the study failed to reliably identify clinical errors in the AI reports, some of them significant. The finding, the researchers said, highlights an urgent need for improvement and the importance of designing high-fidelity scoring systems that faithfully and accurately monitor tool performance. 

The team tested various scoring metrics on AI-generated narrative reports. The researchers also asked six human radiologists to read the AI-generated reports. 

The analysis showed that compared with human radiologists, automated scoring systems fared worse in their ability to evaluate the AI-generated reports. They misinterpreted and, in some cases, overlooked clinical errors made by the AI tool. 

“Accurately evaluating AI systems is the critical first step toward generating radiology reports that are clinically useful and trustworthy,” said study senior author Pranav Rajpurkar, assistant professor of biomedical informatics in the Blavatnik Institute at HMS. 

Improving the score 

In an effort to design better scoring metrics, the team designed a new method (RadGraph F1) for evaluating the performance of AI tools that automatically generate radiology reports from medical images. 

They also designed a composite evaluation tool (RadCliQ) that combines multiple metrics into a single score that better matches how a human radiologist would evaluate an AI model’s performance. 

Using these new scoring tools to evaluate several state-of-the-art AI models, the researchers found a notable gap between the models’ actual score and the top possible score. 

“Measuring progress is imperative for advancing AI in medicine to the next level,” said co-first author Feiyang ‘Kathy’ Yu, a research associate in the Rajpurkar lab. “Our quantitative analysis moves us closer to AI that augments radiologists to provide better patient care.” 

Long term, the researchers’ vision is to build generalist medical AI models that perform a range of complex tasks, including the ability to solve problems never before encountered. Such systems, Rajpurkar said, could fluently converse with radiologists and physicians about medical images to assist in diagnosis and treatment decisions. 

The team also aims to develop AI assistants that can explain and contextualize imaging findings directly to patients using everyday plain language. 

“By aligning better with radiologists, our new metrics will accelerate development of AI that integrates seamlessly into the clinical workflow to improve patient care,” Rajpurkar said. 

For more information: 


Related Artificial Intelligence Content: 

AiMed Global Summit 2023 to Focus on “Changing Healthcare One Connection at a Time” in San Diego 

AiMed Global Summit’s Lineup Announced 

AiMed 2023: Changing Healthcare One Connection at a Time 

Find more AiMed23 conference coverage here 

The Pros and Cons of Using ChatGPT in Clinical Radiology: An Open Discussion 

ChatGPT Passes Radiology Board Exam 

RamSoft Harnesses ChatGPT to Supercharge Their Medical Imaging Patient App, Blume - Launch at HIMSS 2023 

JNM Explores Potential Applications for ChatGPT in Nuclear Medicine and Molecular Imaging 

New Research Suggests AI Image Generation Using DALL-E 2 has Promising Future in Radiology 

Related Content

Feature | RSNA | Christine Book

November 29, 2023 — Following the theme of the Radiological Society of North America Scientific Assembly and Annual ...

Time November 29, 2023
News | Digital Radiography (DR)

November 28, 2023 — Canon Medical Components USA (CMCU) - Digital Radiography (DR), global leaders in advanced flat ...

Time November 28, 2023
News | Computed Tomography (CT)

November 28, 2023 — Smoking marijuana in combination with cigarettes may lead to increased damage of the lung’s air sacs ...

Time November 28, 2023
Feature | RSNA | Christine Book

November 28, 2023 — By early Monday morning, on the second day of RSNA 2023, there were significant news announcements ...

Time November 28, 2023
News | Artificial Intelligence

November 27, 2023 — Mass General Brigham and today announced a collaboration to bring together their ...

Time November 27, 2023
News | Breast Imaging

November 27, 2023 — Barco announces introduction of the DL Precise AI software in addition to the current Intuitive ...

Time November 27, 2023
Feature | RSNA

November 27, 2023 — The collective anticipation of the radiology community was palpable from early morning through ...

Time November 27, 2023
News | RSNA

November 27, 2023 — Black patients underwent medical imaging for cognitive impairment years later than white and ...

Time November 27, 2023
News | Quality Assurance (QA)

November 25, 2023 — Mirion announced that it will debut the new Instadose VUE personal dosimeter, from its Dosimetry ...

Time November 25, 2023
News | Radiology Imaging

November 23, 2023 — Fujifilm Healthcare Americas Corporation, a leading provider of diagnostic and enterprise imaging ...

Time November 23, 2023
Subscribe Now