News | November 24, 2009

Healthcare Bill Excludes Mammograms for Women 40-49

November 24, 2009 – Several sections of Senate healthcare reform legislation would exclude mammography services for women 40-49, noted the American College of Radiology (ACR) in a public statement issued today.

The bill contains language stipulating that insurance entities such as private insurers, Medicare and Medicaid would only be required to cover services receiving a specific grade from the U.S. Preventative Services Task Force (USPSTF). Based on the USPSTF’s recent recommendation, this would exclude mammography services for women 40-49, would only require coverage of biennial coverage for women 50-74, and would exclude coverage for those 74 and older.

The Medicare Improvements for Patients and Providers Act of 2008 (MIPPA) gave the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services the authority to consider USPSTF recommendations in Medicare coverage determinations. Private insurers may also incorporate the USPSTF recommendations as a cost-savings measure.

In a public statement, the ACR warned that while these USPSTF recommendations may result in cost savings, a great many women will subsequently die unnecessarily from breast cancer as a result.

In the statement, James H. Thrall, M.D., FACR, chair of the ACR Board of Chancellors urges Congress to act to specifically protect annual mammography coverage for women ages 40 and older and for high risk women under 40 as recommended by their physician. “If the cost cutting USPSTF mammography recommendations are not excluded from healthcare reform legislation, the government or private insurers would be permitted to refuse women coverage for this life-saving exam, turning back the clock on two decades of advances against the nation’s second leading cancer killer,” said Thrall.

The federally funded and staffed Task Force includes representatives from major health insurers, but does not include a single radiologist, oncologist, breast surgeon, or any other clinician with demonstrated expertise in breast cancer diagnosis or treatment. Despite demonstration by their own analyses that screening annually beginning at age 40 saves the most lives and most years of life, the Task Force recommended against: mammography screening for women 40-49 years of age, annual mammograms for women between 50 and 74 (in favor of only every other year), and all breast cancer screening in women over 74. These recommendations run counter to even the Task Force’s own data and are out of touch with the long-proven policies of the American Cancer Society, ACR and other experts in the field.

“I strongly urge those in Congress to exclude the USPSTF guidelines from health care legislation and make changes to the Task Force membership and operating process that will guard against such unacceptable recommendations moving forward without any input from experts in breast cancer diagnosis and treatment,” said W. Phil Evans, M.D., FACR, president of the Society of Breast Imaging (SBI).

Since the onset of regular mammography screening in 1990, the mortality rate from breast cancer, which had been unchanged for the preceding 50 years, has decreased by 30 percent. According to the statement by the ACR, “ignoring direct scientific evidence from large clinical trials, the USPSTF based their recommendations to reduce breast cancer screening on conflicting computer models and the unsupported and discredited idea that the parameters of mammography screening change abruptly at age 50. In truth, there are no data to support this premise.”

The benefits vs. concerns of annual screening mammography starting at age 40

• Mammography has reduced the breast cancer death rate in the United States by 30 percent since 1990 ? hardly a small benefit.

• Based on data on the performance of screening mammography as it is currently practiced in the United States, one invasive cancer is found for every 556 mammograms performed in women in their 40s.

• Mammography only every other year in women 50-74 would miss 19 to 33 percent of cancers that could be detected by annual screening.

• Starting at age 50 would sacrifice 33 years of life per 1,000 women screened that could have been saved had screening started at age 40.

• Eighty-five percent of all abnormal mammograms require only additional images to clarify whether cancer may be present (or not). Only 2 percent of women who receive screening mammograms eventually require biopsy. The USPSTF data showed that the rate of biopsy is actually lower among younger women.

“Allowing a small number of people with no demonstrated expertise in the subject matter to make recommendations regarding diagnosis of a disease which kills more than 40,000 women each year makes no scientific sense and is a mistake that many women will pay for with their lives. Lawmakers need to require that the USPSTF include experts from the field on which they are making recommendations, and that its recommendations be submitted for comment and review to outside stakeholders in similar fashion to rules enacted by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services,” said Thrall.

For more information: www.acr-arrs.org and http://www.acr.org/HomePageCategories/News/ACRNewsCenter/ExcludedUSPSTFR...

Related Content

Comparison of Screening Recommendations Supports Annual Mammography
News | Mammography | August 22, 2017
When to initiate screening for breast cancer, how often to screen, and how long to screen are questions that continue...
Sponsored Content | Videos | Breast Imaging | July 28, 2017
Nancy Cappello, Ph.D., executive director and founder of Are You Dense Inc. and Are You Dense Advocacy, explains how
Volpara Solutions to Showcase Volpara Enterprise DDP Software at AHRA 2017
News | Mammography | July 11, 2017
Volpara Solutions Inc. will showcase its new Volpara Enterprise DDP software at the Association for Medical Imaging...
Fujifilm Showcases Digital Radiography, Mammography Innovations at AHRA 2017
News | Digital Radiography (DR) | July 06, 2017
Fujifilm Medical Systems U.S.A. Inc. will present its comprehensive portfolio of digital radiography (DR) and...
Solis Mammography Ranks No. 19 in Dallas Business Journal’s Middle Market 50
News | Mammography | June 30, 2017
June 30, 2017 — Solis Mammography was named the 19th fastest-growing, middle-market company in North Texas by the
GE Healthcare Announces First U.S. Installation of Senographe Pristina Mammography System
News | Mammography | June 29, 2017
GE Healthcare has collaborated with Boca Raton Regional Hospital (Boca Raton, Fla.) to bring a more comfortable...
New Study Highlights Breakthrough Therapy to Reduce Mammographic Breast Density
News | Breast Density | June 28, 2017
Stephen N. Birrell, M.D., Ph.D., presented breakthrough findings into the reduction of mammographic breast density at...
Therapixel Wins the Digital Mammography Challenge
News | Mammography | June 23, 2017
June 23, 2017 — French radiology technology company Therapixel was recently named the winner of the Digital Mammograp
MRI Plus Mammography Improves Detection of New Breast Cancer After Surgery
News | Breast Imaging | June 22, 2017
A new article published by JAMA Oncology compares outcomes for combined mammography and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI...
mammogram

Photo courtesy of Barco

News | Mammography | June 08, 2017
An analysis of breast cancer data revealed that many small breast cancers have an excellent prognosis because they are...
Overlay Init