News | May 09, 2012

ASBD Disputes Breast Brachytherapy Study Published in JAMA

Cianna Medical's SAVI is used for breast brachytherapy.

May 9, 2012 - The American Society of Breast Disease (ASBD) is concerned about misleading information in a recent study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA), comparing breast brachytherapy to whole breast irradiation (WBI).

ASBD cautions that the study has several deficiencies that may unnecessarily deter women from choosing brachytherapy as a treatment option. The society believes that brachytherapy remains a valuable method of treatment for appropriately selected patients, and that it should continue to be offered to appropriate women as a treatment choice. Potential benefits include less dose to healthy tissue, convenience (five days instead of six weeks for WBI), safety and effectiveness.

The study's senior author is Benjamin Smith, M.D., assistant professor at MD Anderson's Department of Radiation Oncology. The publication is based on Medicare billing claims data. The study reports a small increased rate of complications among patients treated with brachytherapy, compared to those treated with WBI. However, concern arises regarding the study due to multiple design flaws.

Patients in this study were treated at institutions from across the entire United States, with varying degrees of brachytherapy experience and expertise in medical physics, potentially resulting in the small differences reported. Because of the large number of patients in this study, small differences, such as the 1.77% increase in mastectomy rates, may have achieved statistical significance that are not clinically significant.

Among shortcomings of the study are:

  • It was not a clinical trial with strict entry criteria.
  • Patients in the analysis were treated in the first few years afterballoon brachytherapy was FDA-approved in 2002, when surgeons/ radiation oncologists/medical physicists were just beginning the learning curve.
  • The study was based on older single-channel technology and techniques that were unable to control the skin and rib dose, as clinicians now can do.
  • Key risk factors for breast cancer recurrence were not known or presented.
  • Important treatment details such as chemotherapy and the quality of brachytherapy were absent.
  • There was no mention of actual cancer recurrence rates.
  • The publication lacks helpful information about how current patients should be managed, in view of subsequent advances in brachytherapy technology that are available today.


Background on Technology Advances

The information contained in the JAMA article compares WBI only to the initial, single-catheter "balloon" style brachytherapy device.

More recently, new medical technologies have been introduced to improve patient outcomes. As technology and surgical techniques improve, it is common to see improvements in complication rates.

Since 2006, more sophisticated brachytherapy devices with multiple catheters have become available. These include a "strut-based" applicator and "multi-lumen" applicators. These devices have been proven clinically and studied in standard scientific fashion with peer-reviewed publications supporting their safety and efficacy.

As a result, many doctors have moved away from relying on the older single-channel device, in favor of more advanced brachytherapy devices. These newer devices more precisely deliver radiotherapy and help overcome the limitations of the single-channel balloon method.

The timing of brachytherapy has been found to influence complication rates such as infection and wound healing. For example, the study included data from several years when the brachytherapy applicator was inserted at the time of lumpectomy surgery. That approach likely contributed to the slightly higher brachytherapy complication rates seen in the study. Today, recommendations call for brachytherapy to begin two to four weeks after lumpectomy. When recommended steps for treatment are followed, complication rates are significantly reduced.

Additional Issues with the JAMA Study

It is worth noting that the JAMA data on five-year survival rates were in fact slightly better for brachytherapy patients than for those who received traditional whole breast irradiation.

The JAMA article reported slightly higher rates of mastectomy (1.77% more) and more complications for brachytherapy using the single-channel balloon, compared to WBI. One significant issue here is that the JAMA study did not state -- nor do the authors know -- the cause of those mastectomies, or even which breast was removed. The study suggested this is due to tumor recurrence with brachytherapy, when in fact the data did not reveal the reason for those mastectomies.

The JAMA study also misleadingly emphasized minor complications of radiation therapy (for example, inferior cosmetic outcomes). Yet it failed to highlight the importance of a potentially life-threatening complication of WBI -- post-radiation pneumonitis. The study reports that the pneumonitis complication rate for whole breast irradiation was actually higher than for brachytherapy.

When patients are given a choice between whole breast irradiation and brachytherapy, many will place more weight on avoiding a potentially life-threatening complication such as post-radiation pneumonitis.

Overall, the JAMA study sheds no light on the remaining issues that are important to clinicians. It includes no guidance on patient selection for different kinds of radiation, an important consideration in the treatment of early-stage breast cancer. There is no information gained from this study that will help a woman decide whether or not she is a candidate for breast brachytherapy.

ASBD supports further investigation and the completion of the essential NSABP-39 clinical trial. Many of the remaining questions will be addressed with the data being gathered in randomized, head-to-head clinical trials comparing breast brachytherapy to whole breast irradiation. It is noteworthy that there are 9 randomized clinical trials across the world that will shed light on these critical issues.

Brachytherapy/ partial breast irradiation is one of the most carefully studied technologies in modern medicine, with peer-reviewed published reports demonstrating outcomes that match WBI, and with distinct potential quality-of-life advantages. It would be unfortunate if the deficiencies in the JAMA study limit women's access to breast-cancer therapy choices or prevent completion of the important North American clinical trial.

For more information: and

Related Content

MRI Reveals Striking Brain Differences in People with Genetic Autism

Example images for a control participant , a deletion carrier, and a duplication carrier. In the sagittal image of the deletion carrier, the thick corpus callosum, dens and craniocervical abnormality, and cerebellar ectopia are shown. For the duplication carrier, the sagittal image shows the thin corpus callosum and the axial image shows the increased ventricle size and decreased white matter volume. Image courtesy of the Radiological Society of North America (RSNA).

News | Neuro Imaging | August 09, 2017
August 9, 2017 — In the first major study of its kind, researchers using magnetic...
Clinical Data Supports Use of Xoft System for Endometrial Cancer
News | Brachytherapy Systems | August 03, 2017
Researchers presented clinical data supporting use of the Xoft Axxent Electronic Brachytherapy (eBx) System for the...
brain with chronic traumatic injury
News | Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) | August 02, 2017
Fighters are exposed to repeated mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI), which has been associated with neurodegenerative...
NIH-funded scientists have discovered that Parkinson’s disease increases the amount of “free” water in a particular brain area

NIH-funded scientists have discovered that Parkinson’s disease increases the amount of “free” water in a particular brain area. Image courtesy of David Vaillancourt, Ph.D., University of Florida.

News | Neuro Imaging | July 31, 2017
Scientists at the University of Florida have discovered a new method of observing the brain changes caused by Parkinson...
more healthcare providers and patients are choosing options such as Gamma Knife stereotactic radiosurgery
News | Radiation Therapy | July 31, 2017
Each year, up to 650,000 people who were previously diagnosed with various forms of cancer will develop brain...
"Residual Echo" of Ancient Humans May Hold Clues to Mental Disorders

MRI data shows (left) areas of the skull preferentially affected by the amount of Neanderthal-derived DNA and (right) areas of the brain’s visual system in which Neanderthal gene variants influenced cortex folding (red) and gray matter volume (yellow). Image courtesy of Michael Gregory, M.D., NIMH Section on Integrative Neuroimaging

News | Neuro Imaging | July 26, 2017
Researchers from the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) have produced the first direct evidence that parts of...
New York Hospital Finds Significant Cost Savings With Toshiba’s Aquilion One CT
News | Computed Tomography (CT) | July 25, 2017
In five years, Kaleida Health’s Stroke Care Center (SCC) at the Gates Vascular Institute in Buffalo, N.Y., has realized...
Radiotherapy Prior to Surgery Reduces Secondary Tumor Risk in Early-Stage Breast Cancer Patients
News | Radiation Therapy | July 24, 2017
Moffitt Cancer Center researchers launched a first-of-its-kind study comparing the long-term benefits of radiation...
Electronic Brachytherapy Comparable to Mohs Surgery in Early-Stage Non-Melanoma Skin Cancer Treatment
News | Brachytherapy Systems | July 20, 2017
July 20, 2017 — Rates of recurrence in early-stage non-melanoma skin cancer (NMSC) patients were virtually identical
Overlay Init