Feature | Proton Therapy | July 06, 2020 | By Minesh Mehta, M.D.

Proton Therapy Predictions for the Next Decade

Proton therapy has evolved, and future predictions include smaller systems, more sophisticated proton dosimetry and devices that manipulate the proton beam

Proton therapy has evolved, and future predictions include smaller systems, more sophisticated proton dosimetry and devices that manipulate the proton beam

The field of proton therapy is continuing to see explosive growth. In the past decade alone, technological advances have made proton therapy a more accessible, viable option for hospitals and radiotherapy centers. Moreover, clinical applications for proton therapy have evolved, enabling the treatment of a broad range of diseases. 

As we look ahead to the next 10 years, exciting advances in proton therapy are on the horizon. Among our predictions: proton therapy systems will continue to get smaller, proton dosimetry will become significantly more sophisticated, and devices to manipulate the size and shape of the proton beam, such as multi-leaf collimators, will permit treatment of large complex tumors, as well as very small lesions. 

Continued Miniaturization of Proton Therapy Technology 

Once limited to only a handful of cancer centers due to its expansive size and prohibitive cost, proton therapy hardware evolved in the 1990s to a smaller profile, making the technology more accessible. That said, the size of the equipment is still measurable, with a large footprint, presenting a substantial challenge to legacy radiation oncology departments looking to retrofit the technology into existing spaces. However, this obstacle is slowly being overcome through miniaturization. 

Recent advances have already miniaturized the footprint of proton therapy technology — by as much as 30 to 40 percent. These developments include the advent of superconducting magnet technology, allowing for the size of the cyclotron, which produces the proton beam, to be compressed. Additionally, the rotating gantry, which was historically housed in a three-story building, can now be significantly minimized in size.

Looking ahead, radical new technologies for the generation of proton beams accelerated to very high energy are predicted to dramatically decrease equipment size and shielding requirements. These new developments, including technologies such as proton plasma wakefield acceleration and dielectric wall accelerator technology, will likely be significantly more affordable and could easily be retrofitted into existing radiotherapy departments. Several research laboratories have already created non-clinical devices based on these radical new technologies, several of which, parenthetically, are a “spin-off” of the “Star Wars” program. 

A major advantage of these miniaturized technology platforms would be a substantial reduction in acquisition and operational costs, which would make proton therapy more affordable and significantly more competitive as an option in treating different types of cancer. Broader availability of proton technology would also open doors for a generation of new data to assist with and help enhance research and clinical trials. 

 

Improving the Precision of Beam Delivery

The current generation of proton therapy platforms incorporate on-board patient imaging to assure precise positioning. This is typically performed immediately prior to the proton beam delivery. Although patient positioning precision has improved substantially, during the actual “beam-on” period, there remains some uncertainty regarding the precise delivery of the beam. 

To solve this problem, proton therapy centers have incorporated multiple, in-room, ceiling-mounted cameras to provide continuous feedback regarding the patient’s surface anatomy. These cameras alert the treating team of significant variations or movement so they can stop the beam to reposition the patient. However, this is mostly a manual process. The next generation of technology is predicted to fully integrate these imaging technologies into a robotic/automatic feedback loop so that the physician can define the motion threshold that is acceptable. If the patient drifts beyond these boundaries, the system would automatically beam off — and similarly would beam back on — once the patient is within the predefined boundary parameters. Very early in development are efforts to consider incorporating onboard continuous MR imaging, which would provide near real-time feedback and could be used to gate the beam delivery process with unprecedented accuracy.

Enhanced Proton Dosimetry Computation

Historically, proton dosimetry relied on computer modeling to generate dose distributions. These models have certain limitations in terms of defining the exact depth at which protons would stop, their interaction with tissues of different density and the impact of motion on the dose distribution. Clinically, this is currently overcome through a laborious process known as robustness optimization and evaluation. 

Several advances are expected to be made in verifying the actual dose delivered to the patient during treatment. Some technologies currently underway have the potential to resolve this limitation. They include the ability to perform a PET scan immediately after completion of proton therapy. Since proton therapy can induce positron production, a rapid acquisition of a PET image can help localize the region of high-dose delivery. Additionally, researchers are working on a technique known as proton radiography, which produces the equivalent of an X-ray using a proton beam to assist with patient positioning and dose verification. Another technology under investigation is known as prompt gamma imaging — when the interaction of protons with tissue produces a small amount of gamma radiation that can be detected with highly sophisticated gamma cameras. In the near future, it is expected that these cameras will precisely detect where the actual dose was delivered.

Further Shaping of the Proton Beam

Multi-leaf collimators (MLCs) have revolutionized the delivery of high-energy X-ray or photon radiation, contributing to the speed and precision of targeting cancerous tumors. However, early work with MLCs was largely abandoned due to a myriad of issues, including the production of neutrons from protons bombarding its metal make-up, which have the potential for causing secondary malignancies. However, the advent of newer technologies has allowed for a resurrection in research on MLCs for proton therapy. 

Several teams are working on very finely collimated, rapidly responsive collimation systems made of newer materials with significant reduction in neutron production. These have the potential for improving the lateral dose distribution of the proton beam. This would be substantially advantageous, especially in patients receiving reirradiation.

Beyond the development of MLC technology for the treatment of large tumors, the targeting and treatment of small tumors also requires substantial refinement of this technology. One trend we see evolving is using MLCs to treat small eye tumors, using continuous laser guidance. This concept was originally pioneered in the field of ophthalmology for laser targeting of small lesions within the eye. Today, these tumors can be treated, but require a substantial hardware solution. Laser-based guidance combined with highly sophisticated beam collimation would permit smaller tumors to be treated more easily, minimizing the amount of required hardware.

 

Minesh Mehta, M.D., is deputy director and chief of radiation oncology at Miami Cancer Institute, a part of Baptist Health South Florida. He is a widely renowned expert in radiation oncology, proton therapy and cancer research. Mehta is Board-certified in radiation oncology by the American Board of Radiology and in neuro-oncology by the United Council for Neurologic Subspecialties.

 

Related Proton Therapy Content:

Proton Therapy in 2020: Where We Are and How We Got Here

 

Related Content

The 15-ton compact accelerator is lifted into the David C. Pratt Cancer Center at Mercy St. Louis. (Photo: Business Wire)

The 15-ton compact accelerator is lifted into the David C. Pratt Cancer Center at Mercy St. Louis. (Photo: Business Wire)

News | Radiation Oncology | July 21, 2021
July 23, 2021 — Mevion Medical Systems announced that it has delivered the 15-ton compact accelerator to...
ASTRO just issued the following statement in response to the Radiation Oncology Model update in yesterday's HOPPS proposed rule, which compounds significant and detrimental cuts to the cancer care specialty in the proposed 2022 MPFS

Getty Images

News | Radiation Therapy | July 20, 2021
July 20, 2021 — In response to consecutive weeks of proposed...
Artificial intelligence-powered diagnostic tool spots asymptomatic prostate cancer in seconds

(L-R) Associate Professor Peter Brotchie (St Vincent's), Dr Ruwan Tennakoon (RMIT), Professor John Thangarajah (RMIT), Dr Mark Page (St Vincent's). Image courtesy of St Vincent's Hospital Melbourne

News | Prostate Cancer | July 19, 2021
July 19, 2021 — Prostate cancer is the most diagnosed
Ramon Alfredo Siochi, Ph.D. — the director of medical physics at WVU — led a task group to help ensure the accuracy of data that dictates a cancer patient's radiation therapy.

Ramon Alfredo Siochi, director of medical physics at West Virginia University. Image courtesy of WVU Photo/Aira Burkhart

News | Radiation Oncology | July 15, 2021
July 15, 2021 — Just as helicopter traffic reporters use their "bird's eye view" to route drivers around roadblocks s
NeuroLogica joins forces with Massachusetts General Hospital to pilot OmniTom Elite with Photon Counting Detector (PCD) technology at patient point-of-care

NeuroLogica joins forces with Massachusetts General Hospital to pilot OmniTom Elite with Photon Counting Detector (PCD) technology at patient point-of-care. (Photo: Business Wire)

News | Computed Tomography (CT) | July 13, 2021
July 13, 2021 — NeuroLogica Corp.
 The numbers of cancer screening tests rebounded sharply in the last quarter of 2020, following a dramatic decline in the first months of the COVID-19 pandemic, at one large hospital system in the Northeastern United States. These findings were released in a study published in Cancer Cell. The research also found an increase in racial and socioeconomic disparities among users of some screening tests during the pandemic.

Getty Images

News | Radiation Oncology | July 12, 2021
July 12, 2021 — The numbers of...
To help enhance the images and information provided to clinicians for radiation oncology treatment planning, GE Healthcare will integrate Spectronic Medical’s AI-based software with its industry leading AIR Recon DL technology
News | Artificial Intelligence | July 09, 2021
July 9, 2021 — GE Healthcare announced the integration of S...
American Society for Radiation Oncology (ASTRO) to host in-person Annual Meeting in Chicago, October 24-27

Getty Images

News | ASTRO | July 08, 2021
July 8, 2021 — Registration opens today for the American Society for Radiation Oncology's (...