Feature | April 09, 2014 | Barbara S. Schwartzberg, M.D.

Intraoperative Radiation Therapy for Early Stage Breast Cancer

Intraoperative Radiation Therapy (IORT) procedure in four steps.

The Xoft Axxent Controller, balloon and mini X-ray source assembled to simulate use during IORT.

The current standard of care for treatment of early stage breast cancer is mastectomy or lumpectomy followed by five to seven weeks of daily whole breast radiation therapy (WBRT) treatments. Post-operative accelerated partial breast irradiation (APBI) is slowly replacing whole breast external beam irradiation as an alternative in treatment of early stage lymph node-negative breast cancer. This was originally performed as limited-field breast brachytherapy using multiple interstitial catheters placed post-operatively around the lumpectomy site. Radioactive interstitial wire implants were then placed into the catheters. 

More recently, APBI has been delivered as post-operative intensity-modulated radiotherapy, 3-D conformal radiotherapy or balloon catheter radiotherapy. APBI is usually delivered to the lumpectomy site in 10 post-operative fractions given twice a day, six hours apart, throughout the course of five days. Results to date from all four techniques are favorable, showing good cosmesis and recurrence rates comparable to standard whole breast irradiation.

Trial Studies

Intraoperative radiation therapy (IORT) allows for delivery of a single fraction of radiation to the lumpectomy site while still in the operating room. The use of IORT has been reported in two European studies. The ELIOT trial, published by Veronesi in 2008, reported the results of 1,246 patients treated with intraoperative electron beam radiotherapy using the Sordina IORT Technologies’ Novac 7 and Liac devices.1 Five-year survival was roughly calculated to be 96.5 percent. New primary carcinoma diagnosed in other breast quadrants was 1.3 percent. Four-year follow-up data for another trial, the TARGIT-A trial, was published by Vaiyda in 2010. The Zeiss Intrabeam device was used to treat 1,232 patients.2 Results were considered equivalent to lumpectomy followed by five weeks of standard whole breast irradiation. Five-year follow-up TARGIT-A trial data has been presented for 1,222 patients, showing that IORT still meets non-inferiority criteria when compared to WBRT.3 IORT is now also available using a disposable balloon applicator device as part of the Xoft electronic brachytherapy system. Results of 11 patients receiving a single 20 Gy intraoperative fraction were reported by Ivanov in 2010.4 Mean follow-up was for 12 months. There were no cancer recurrences in this short follow-up time interval. The results of 40 patients using the Xoft System were presented  in 2013.5 There were no recurrences after a mean follow-up of 15 months.

Reduced Treatment Time

Intraoperative radiation therapy using electronic brachytherapy for treatment of early stage breast cancer is currently under investigation. Electronic brachytherapy is delivered using portable equipment that runs conventional electricity over a tungsten or gold crystal to produce radiation. The resultant radiation has a short penetration, allowing for use in the operating room. Leaded bunkered rooms are no longer necessary. The personnel and patients are protected by standard leaded drapes and portable shields. The balloon applicator is placed into the lumpectomy cavity and then attached to a controller. 

Doses, which are individually calculated, are dependent on the size and conformation of the lumpectomy cavity. Most IORT clinical trials include women with a single focus of biopsy-proven invasive ductal carcinoma who have cancer-free lymph nodes. Some trials include women who have been diagnosed with ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS). If enrolled, patients undergo a standard sentinel lymph node (SLN) analysis and lumpectomy with intraoperative margin evaluation. The SLNs must be cancer-free. Adequate margins are determined radiographically and on gross examination by the pathologist. If cleared by these parameters, a shield is placed against the chest wall to protect the underlying organs. A balloon applicator attached to the Xoft System is placed into the lumpectomy cavity. Intraoperative ultrasound is used to document good apposition of surrounding breast tissue and an acceptable distance between skin and applicator surface. Patients receive a single fraction of electronic brachytherapy through the applicator of 20 Gy. The applicator and shield are then removed and the operation is completed using current standards of care. Final pathology confirms adequate margins and that the SLNs are cancer-free. Additional treatment recommendations follow local medical standards. 

IORT is well tolerated by patients and is usually performed in an outpatient setting. Patients are pleased both with the cosmetic outcome and convenience of the procedure. The cosmetic results are favorable as the radiation is localized to only the lumpectomy site. They are no longer inconvenienced by a five- to seven-week schedule of daily post-operative whole breast irradiation. It is predicted that this will reduce treatment costs.

Promising Alternative

Intraoperative radiation treatment using electronic brachytherapy has shown promise as an alternative to other forms of APBI or whole breast irradiation in the treatment of patients with early stage node negative breast cancer. Clinical trials documenting long-term outcomes are in progress.  


1. Veronesi U, Orecchia R, Luini A, et al. “Full dose Intraoperative radiotherapy with electrons (ELIOT) during breast conserving surgery. Experience with 1246 cases.” ECancer Medical Science. Volume: 1 Article Number: 65, 2008.

2. Vaidya JS, Joseph DJ, Tobias JS, et al. “Targeted intraoperative
radiotherapy versus whole breast radiotherapy for breast cancer (TARGIT-A trial): an international, prospective, randomized,
non-inferiority phase 3 trial.” Lancet 2010; 376 (9735), 91-102.

3. Vaidja JS. San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium, Dec. 4-8, 2012.

4. Ivanov O, Dickler A, Lum BY, et al. “Twelve-month follow-up results of a trial utilizing Axxent electronic brachytherapy to deliver intraoperative radiation therapy for early-stage breast cancer.” Ann Surg Oncol 2011;18(2): 453-458.

5. Schwartzberg, BS. American Society of Breast Surgeons 14th Annual Meeting, Chicago, May 1-5, 2013.

Barbara Schwartzberg, M.D., is a private practice breast surgeon at Rose Medical Center in Denver, Colo. She received her B.A. in chemistry from Franklin and Marshall College, her M.S. in pharmaceutical chemistry from Purdue University and her M.D. from George Washington University before doing her general surgery residency at the University of Colorado. She enjoys researching new technologies that allow for easier, more targeted treatment of early stage breast cancer.

Related Content

Clinical Trial Testing Topical Gel to Reduce Breast Density
News | Breast Density | June 19, 2018
Women with dense breast tissue soon might be adding a new product to their skincare routine to help them fight breast...
California Women In Favor of Extending State's Breast Density Inform Law
News | Breast Density | June 15, 2018
A recent survey of California women found that 95 percent of respondents want the state’s breast density inform law to...
Women More Likely to Use Other Preventive Health Services Following Mammography
News | Mammography | June 13, 2018
Medicare beneficiaries who undergo breast cancer screening with mammography are more likely than unscreened women to...
How AI and Deep Learning Will Enable Cancer Diagnosis Via Ultrasound

The red outline shows the manually segmented boundary of a carcinoma, while the deep learning-predicted boundaries are shown in blue, green and cyan. Copyright 2018 Kumar et al. under Creative Commons Attribution License.

News | Ultrasound Imaging | June 12, 2018 | Tony Kontzer
June 12, 2018 — Viksit Kumar didn’t know his mother had...
Breast imaging technologies have seen a rapid evolution.

Breast imaging technologies have seen a rapid evolution.

Feature | Women's Health | June 05, 2018 | By Jeff Zagoudis
Breast imaging technologies have evolved rapidly in the last two decades to help physicians detect breast cancers at
Raysearch RayStation
Feature | Radiation Therapy | June 05, 2018 | By Melinda Taschetta-Millane
Treatment planning systems are at the heart of r...
Lung Decision Precision
News | Lung Cancer | June 04, 2018
For smokers and former smokers, the threat of lung cancer always lurks in the shadows.
Breast Cancer Survivors Not Getting Recommended Number of Mammograms Post-Surgery
News | Mammography | May 24, 2018
Breast cancer survivors are not getting the recommended level of screening post-surgery, according to a newly-published...
Overlay Init