Feature | April 01, 2015 | Jeff Zagoudis

Critical Issues Facing Radiology

As new payment models and quality measures are introduced, radiologists must prove their value to stay ahead of the curve

Critical Issues Facing Radiology.
Critical Issues Facing Radiology

Radiology value-added matrix.

The landscape of the healthcare industry is poised for dramatic change in 2015 and the years ahead, and radiologists need to be ready to adapt if they’re going to thrive. This was the overarching message from the plenary session “Critical Issues Facing the Practice of Radiology in 2015 and Beyond” at RSNA 2014, presented by Bibb Allen, Jr., M.D., FACR; Geraldine McGinty, M.D., FACR; and James A. Brink, M.D., FACR, all members of the American College of Radiology (ACR) Board of Chancellors. 

Declining Reimbursements

The largest issue looming on the horizon, by all accounts, is the transition from fee-for-service to a value-based payment model. Allen termed the shift a “revalidation of current inputs,” as the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) works through the current procedure terminology (CPT) codes to determine what codes can be eliminated or bundled together. From radiology’s standpoint, Allen noted that many technical component codes are already being eliminated. As more and more codes are bundled or eliminated, exam volume has begun to decline and will continue to do so for the foreseeable future. 

Resetting the scales to a value-based payment system is slowly but surely leveling the playing field for reimbursements, with payments equalizing across the board. At the same time, however, this raises concerns about the growing commoditization of healthcare in general, and radiology specifically. “If all we have to offer is radiological interpretation, it doesn’t really matter who that interpretation is done by or where that person is,” Allen said. “It’s just a diagnosis at the bottom of a sheet of paper. It is a service that is fairly uniform and can be traded on a market totally based on price.” 

The key, he said, is adapting to healthcare reform, which centers on four ideas:

•  Better health for the population

•  Better care for individuals

•  Lower cost through improvements

•  More patient-centric focus 

What’s Appropriate? 

Rather than subject a patient to a battery of imaging exams, this more patient-centric, value-based healthcare model focuses on implementing the right treatment or service. With so many different types of imaging exams and each with a myriad of applications, the question becomes how can one be absolutely certain they’re implementing the “right” imaging solution?  

To help radiologists ensure they are taking the best course of action, the ACR released its own appropriateness criteria for clinical decision support (CDS). The document contains evidence-based guidelines for radiological options in response to various conditions and scenarios, along with an appropriateness rating for each option. The appropriateness criteria are regularly updated but are still not widely used at the point of care, according to McGinty.

Radiologists have a little time to get a better understanding of the appropriateness measures, but should have them down by Jan. 1, 2017, when the Clinical Decision Support for Advanced Imaging mandate takes effect. Spawned from the Protecting Access to Medicare Act, the measure will require physicians ordering advanced diagnostic imaging exams to consult a series of government-approved, evidence-based appropriate-use criteria via a CDS system. Claims for the exam will only be reimbursed if the physician can confirm they consulted the system. 

Value-added Radiology

Establishing their place in the new system goes beyond just making appropriate exam choices, though. Radiologists have to become their own advocates and demonstrate quantifiable value — both within and outside of the imaging lab. 

Quantifying exam time is relatively easy, but what about all of the other job-related functions carried out during the day? A tool like the Radiology Value-added Matrix provides one solution. The chart consists of several columns, with header categories such as quality, service, utilization management and professional development. Underneath each column are the related tasks, which can then be broken down into the amount of time spent performing each task. Multiply that number by the average hourly rate for radiologists at your hospital, and a more accurate picture emerges of how radiologists spend their time and what exactly they contribute. See Radiology Value-added Matrix.

Manage the Population

With an increased focus on patient-centered care and the emphasis on decreasing volume, the best way to satisfy these dual objectives is to be more mindful of population health management. This means keeping a population as healthy as possible while minimizing the need for interventions, from hospital visits to imaging exams. “It should be automated and ongoing,” said Brink. 

The process of population health management lays out as follows:

1.  Define the population

2.  Identify the care gaps within that population

3.  Stratify the risks involved with care

4.  Engage the patients 

5.  Manage their care

6.  Measure the outcomes of care

Radiologists play a critical role in the second half of the process, providing data analysis and integration while facilitating improved communication through quality reporting. Executing higher quality reporting is easy to achieve, said McGinty, through a variety of informatics tools, which are one of the key focuses in the ACR’s Imaging 3.0 initiative. Making use of computer-assisted reporting tools can enhance information quality in several areas, including: 

•  Detection of findings

•  Disease classification

•  Recommendations for further action

Electronic health records (EHRs) are just one example of a powerful informatics tool that can be used to help ensure a patient is receiving the proper imaging exam. Many vendors now include safeguards within their software to adjust the workflow if an imaging exam appears to be implemented outside of its standard indications. 

Managing Quality

As these new measures are implemented going forward, radiologists have the opportunity to help each other improve and adapt by coordinating a strong quality management framework. The idea is to get everyone on the same page in terms of quality, safety and performance improvement efforts. 

McGinty put forth the concept of a radiologist value metric dashboard, much like the Radiology Value-added Matrix. Such mechanisms serve a two-fold purpose: They show the value that imaging departments add to clinical care in their own facilities, while also providing concrete data on how they differ from the competition. 

Above all else, being proactive in addressing these critical issues is the key for radiologists to survive and thrive in the changing landscape.

 

Related Radiology Business Transformation Content:

Opportunities for Growth in a Competitive Radiology Climate

VIDEO: The Consolidation Trend in Radiology Business

Must Radiologists Be Prepared To Delegate ... To Smart Machines?

VIDEO: Critical Issues in Radiology Administration

Radiologists Seek Greater Involvement in Patient Care

VIDEO: Role of Medical Imaging in Value-Based Care

 

Related Content

Gadolinium based contrast dye in brain MRI

Gadolinium contrast agents (GBCAs) are partly retained in the brain, raising safety concerns, as seen in this MRI.

News | Contrast Media | January 17, 2020
January 17, 2020 — Bracco Diagnostics Inc., the U.
Imaging Technology News (ITN) has been acquired by Wainscot Media
News | Imaging Technology News - ITN | January 14, 2020
January 14, 2020 — Park Ridge, N.J.-based publisher Wainscot Medi...
Partners of Collaborative Imaging experience billing collection improvements of over 25 percent while reducing operating costs by 30 percent

Image courtesy of Philips Healthcare

News | Radiology Business | January 08, 2020
January 8, 2020 — The $18 billion radiology industry continues to face a growing threat of consolidation, resulting i
The use of augmented and virtual reality in radiology was the subject of two articles and part of the HIMSS 2019 trends article in the top 25 list. Augmented reality is being looked at as a way to better train radiologists, allow surgeons to use medical imaging in true 3-D to better plan surgeries, and it can allow patients to better understand their conditions compared to use of traditional 2-D medical images. Photo by Dave Fornell.

The use of augmented and virtual reality in radiology was the subject of two articles and part of the HIMSS 2019 trends article in the top 25 list. Augmented reality is being looked at as a way to better train radiologists, allow surgeons to use medical imaging in true 3-D to better plan surgeries, and it can allow patients to better understand their conditions compared to use of traditional 2-D medical images. Photo by Dave Fornell.

Feature | Radiology Imaging | January 03, 2020 | Dave Fornell, Editor
January 3, 2020 — Here is the top 25 radiology articles on the Imaging Technology News (ITN) website from 2019 based
This is artificial intelligence on Fujifilm's mobile digital radiography system to immediately detect pneumothorax (a collapsed lung) and show the location to the technologist and attending physician in a unit before the image is even uploaded to the PACS for a read. AI applications like this that have immediate impact on critical patient care saw a lot of interest at RSNA 2019.

This is work-in-progress artificial intelligence app on Fujifilm's mobile digital radiography system to immediately detect pneumothorax (a collapsed lung), The AI highlights the area of interest to show the location to the technologist and attending physician in a unit before the image is even uploaded to the PACS for a read by a radiologist. The technology also can flag the study for an immediate read in the PACS worklist for confirmation by a human. This technology is from a third-party and will be offered on Fujifilm's REiLI AI platform. Applications like this that have immediate impact on critical patient care saw a lot of interest at RSNA 2019. Photos by ITN Editor Dave Fornell.

Feature | Artificial Intelligence | December 27, 2019 | Siddharth Shah and Srikanth Kompalli, Frost & Sullivan
Radiology artificial intelligence (AI) was again the hottest topic at the 2019...
Leading health system leverages Philips diagnostic imaging and patient monitoring solutions to deliver on Quadruple Aim: better outcomes, increased efficiency, and improved patient and staff experience

Vitor Rocha, chief market leader, Philips North America (left) and John DiAngelo, president and CEO, Inspira Health.

News | Radiology Business | December 26, 2019
December 26, 2019 — Philips and...
The Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) presented its eighth Alexander R. Margulis Award for Scientific Excellence to Jae Ho Sohn, M.D., from the Radiology & Biomedical Imaging Department at the University of California in San Francisco (UCSF)

Jae Ho Sohn, M.D.

News | RSNA | December 24, 2019
December 24, 2019 — The Radiological Society of North America (R
Notification of company split related to diagnostic imaging-related business and transfer of shares of a new company, and recognition of extraordinary gain on an unconsolidated basis and other income on a consolidated basis for fiscal year ending March 31, 2021
News | Radiology Business | December 18, 2019
December 18, 2019 —New details have just been released regarding...
The Hitachi Scenaria View CT scanner on display at the 2019 Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) meeting in December. This workhorse 64 or 128 slice CT system, and Hitchai's portfolio of MRI and ultrasound systems, is attracting the attention of Fujifilm, which does not have some of these technologies. Combined, the new new portfolio may help Fufifilm capture a parger portion of international radiology market share. Photo by Dave Fornell.

The Hitachi Scenaria View CT scanner on display at the 2019 Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) meeting in December. This workhorse 64 or 128 slice CT system, and Hitchai's portfolio of MRI and ultrasound systems, is attracting the attention of Fujifilm, which does not have some of these technologies. Combined, the new new portfolio may help Fujifilm capture a larger portion of international radiology market share. Photo by Dave Fornell.

Feature | Radiology Business | December 17, 2019 | Dave Fornell, Editor
December 17, 2019 — It was disclosed today that Fujifilm may buy Hitachi's diagnostic imaging business in a deal that
William T. Thorwarth, M.D., FACR, chief executive officer of the ACR

William T. Thorwarth, M.D., FACR, chief executive officer of the ACR

News | Population Health | December 13, 2019
December 13, 2019 — The ...