Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant
Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant

Greg Freiherr has reported on developments in radiology since 1983. He runs the consulting service, The Freiherr Group.

Blog | Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant | PET-CT| April 06, 2016

How to Achieve the Quantitative Promise of PET/CT

How to Achieve the Quantitative Promise of PET/CT

Image courtesy Siemens Healthcare

The good news for molecular imaging is that the latest generation of PET/CT can visualize more and subtler signs of disease. Even better, these souped-up machines can more precisely measure standard uptake values (SUVs). This adds credence to their role in quantifying what has long been a subjective process of diagnosing, prognosing and following patients.

Unfortunately, that is also the bad news.

The increased precision possible with the latest PET/CT scanners, replete with point-spread function and time-of-flight, is a welcome development for diagnosticians. But it can be a double-edged sword for those who replace an older generation system with a newer one.

Scanning patients on newer, more powerful PET/CTs can reveal lesions that were overlooked earlier, giving the appearance that a therapy is ineffective or the disease has returned. This may happen when the latest images show what were too small to spot on less powerful machines. Additionally, the quantitative measurements may be higher because the latest equipment is more sensitive. Different protocols, some of which may be introduced with the availability of new equipment, may further skew interpretations.

Quantitative measurements — standard uptake values — can be particularly vexing. Ones recorded prior to oncologic therapy provide the baselines against which those acquired during and after therapy are compared. SUVs may be used to set PERCIST (PET response criteria in solid tumors) thresholds for individual patients. Research has documented that an increase of 30 percent or more above the PERCIST threshold indicates poor patient response and that a change in therapy should be considered. Conversely, a decline of 30 percent or more indicates a likely positive effect and that the therapy is working.

SUVs represent a sea of change in medical diagnostics. Their quantitative nature offers a respite from the subjectivity and skill-based diagnostics that characterize modern medicine. The importance of meeting the challenge of data harmonization, presented by data variability, takes on a new dimension when considering multi-site clinical trials. SUVs can be the pivotal metric in trials designed to test the efficacy of experimental therapies. Conclusions may be called into question, if the data are not adjusted to account for technical differences among the sites.

There are ways to handle this apples-and-oranges dilemma. Guidelines developed by international organizations serving the MI community have laid out the process for adjusting SUVs to make them comparable. But the process is not easy. The staff conducting multi-center clinical trials may have the wherewithal to do it, but the everyday practitioner may not.

This is especially disappointing considering the potential of SUVs to increase certainty and confidence in the management of patients. PET/CT is positioned to play a major role in the coming age of value medicine, but only if its quantitative capability results in improved patient outcomes. To have a substantial impact on public health, solutions that allow accurate interpretation must be easy to use. Progress toward this goal is being made.

French researchers have developed a mathematical formula that allows the comparison of data captured using different generations of scanners. They proved this formula can be used to harmonize data obtained during multi-center research on patients with non-small cell lung cancer. The formula has since been productized by an equipment vendor and, in this form, proved to work on data from patients with a wide range of cancers.

Notably, this software has been validated only on generations of equipment made by the vendor that has productized it. Work to extend its ability reach to translate SUVs obtained using generations of scanners made by different manufacturers is underway.

Until the means for translating data is achieved and widely embraced, the benefit that might be derived from quantitatively assessing follow-up patients will be on hold … and with it the hope that molecular imaging might bring increased precision to patient management.

Editor’s note: This is the first blog in a series of four by industry consultant Greg Freiherr on Where Molecular Imaging Fits in Managing the Cancer Patient. To read all of Greg's blogs, click here.

Related Content

Siemens Healthineers Announces FDA Clearance of syngo.via VB30 Molecular Imaging Software
Technology | Nuclear Imaging | July 16, 2018
At the 2018 Annual Meeting of the Society of Nuclear Medicine and Molecular Imaging (SNMMI), June 23-26 in Philadelphia...
Nuclear imaging scan showing very good tissue delineation. Scan performed on a Biograph Vision positron emission tomography/computed tomography (PET-CT) system from Siemens Healthineers.

Nuclear imaging scan showing very good tissue delineation. It offers crisp overall image quality and sharply delineates the muscle and fat planes, vertebral margins and end plates, billiary radicals, renal calyces, aortic wall and papillary muscles of the heart. Scan performed on a Biograph Vision positron emission tomography/computed tomography (PET-CT) system from Siemens Healthineers.

Technology | PET-CT | June 05, 2018
June 5, 2018 — The U.S.
The Chalk River nuclear reactor license has been renewed, but will be decommissioned by 2028.

The Chalk River nuclear isotope reactor license has been renewed, but will be decommissioned by 2028. The reactor supplies about 50 percent of the world's supply of Tc99m.

Feature | Nuclear Imaging | April 02, 2018 | Dave Fornell
April 2, 2018 – The Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) announced March 29 that it renewed Canadian Nuclear Lab
A Tc99m SPECT cardiac exam showing myocardial perfusion in the heart.

Technetium-99m is primarily used for the detection of cancer and to assess perfusion defects in the heart caused by heart attacks or other conditions.

Feature | Radiopharmaceuticals and Tracers | February 08, 2018 | Dave Fornell
February 8, 2018 — The U.S.
Netherlands Cancer Institute Exploring Molecular Imaging Technology for Prostate Cancer Surgery
News | Molecular Imaging | October 26, 2017
The Netherlands Cancer Institute (NKI) announced it has received funding from the Dutch Cancer Society (KWF...
Combined Optical and Molecular Imaging Could Guide Breast-Conserving Surgery

WLE specimen from a patient with a grade 3, ER-/HER2-, no special type (NST) carcinoma. (A) Cerenkov image; (B) Grey-scale photographic image overlaid with Cerenkov signal. An increased signal from the tumor is visible (white arrows); mean radiance is 871 ± 131 photons/s/cm2/sr, mean TBR is 3.22. Both surgeons measured the posterior margin (outlined in blue) as 2 mm (small arrow); a cavity shaving would have been performed if the image had been available intraoperatively. The medial margin (outlined in green) measured >5 mm by both surgeons. Pathology ink prevented assessing the lateral margin; a phosphorescent signal is visible (open arrows). (C) Specimen radiography image. The absence of one surgical clip to mark the anterior margin, and the odd position of the superior margin clip (white arrow) prevented reliable margin assessment. (D) Combined histopathology image from two adjacent pathology slides on which the posterior margin (bottom of image) and part of the primary tumor are visible (open arrows). The distance from the posterior margin measured 3 mm microscopically (double arrow). The medial margin is > 5 mm (not present in image). Credit: A. D. Purushotham, M.D., King’s College London, UK

News | Nuclear Imaging | June 20, 2017
June 20, 2017 — Breast-conserving surgery (BCS) is the primary treatment for early-stage...
A 77-year-old male with recurrent lymph node and pulmonary metastases detected by Ga-68 PSMA PET/CT but not by conventional imaging

A 77-year-old male with recurrent lymph node and pulmonary metastases detected by Ga-68 PSMA PET/CT but not by conventional imaging. Graphic courtesy of the Department of Nuclear Medicine, Royal North Shore Hospital, Sydney

News | Prostate Cancer | June 15, 2017
An estimated one in seven American men will be affected by prostate cancer in their lifetime. Prostate-specific...
Axial fused 89Zr-5B1 antibody PET/CT image demonstrates focus of uptake in the liver (arrow). Focus of uptake correlates with increased liver metastasis seen on diagnostic CT (red arrow) performed 2 weeks prior

Axial fused 89Zr-5B1 antibody PET/CT image demonstrates focus of uptake in the liver (arrow). Focus of uptake correlates with increased liver metastasis seen on diagnostic CT (red arrow) performed 2 weeks prior. Image courtesy of Christian Lohrmann, Jason Lewis, Wolfgang Weber, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center; MabVax Therapeutics

News | PET-CT | June 14, 2017
Pancreatic cancer is associated with bleak five-year survival rates and limited treatment options, but new research is...
Single Dual Time-point PET Scan Identifies Dual Alzheimer's Biomarkers

While subject No. 1 (left) was judged as positive for both the neuronal injury and the amyloid load biomarker, both Alzheimer's disease biomarkers were negative in subject No. 2 (right). Image courtesy of Henryk Barthel et al., University Hospital Leipzig, Leipzig, Germany

News | PET Imaging | June 14, 2017
More people die of Alzheimer's disease than prostate and breast cancer combined. Identifying the disease before major...
Bennett S. Greenspan, M.D.

Bennett S. Greenspan, M.D.

News | Molecular Imaging | June 13, 2017
Bennett S. Greenspan, M.D., MS, FACNM, FACR, professor of radiology at the Medical College of Georgia, Augusta...
Overlay Init