Feature | June 24, 2015

Early-Stage Breast Cancer Imaging Rates for Metastatic Cancer High Despite Guidelines

Canadian study finds 86 percent of women undergo pre- or postoperative imaging for peace of mind, against recommendations

early-stage breast cancer, metastatic, guidelines, CMAJ, University of Ottawa

June 24, 2015 - Most women with early-stage breast cancer will undergo imaging to determine if the cancer has metastasized, despite international guidelines that recommend against testing, found a study in Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ).

Guidelines from the American Society of Clinical Oncology, Cancer Care Ontario and the National Comprehensive Cancer Network recommend against imaging for metastatic cancer in asymptomatic women with stage I or II breast cancer; this is because the likelihood of metastases is low, at 0.2 percent and 1.2 percent, respectively, and the chance of false-positive findings are high. Unnecessary investigation can result in harm because false-positive results can lead to more invasive tests, treatment delays and increased anxiety.

"Despite guidelines against imaging to detect radiologically-evident distant metastases, our results show that this practice is very common among patients with early-stage breast cancer in Ontario," wrote Mark Clemons, M.D., an oncologist at The Ottawa Hospital and the University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, with coauthors.

A study of 26,547 women in Ontario diagnosed with stage I or stage II breast cancer between 2007 and 2012 found that 86 percent (22,811) underwent at least one imaging test to detect whether the cancer had metastasized. Imaging was performed in about 80 percent of women with stage I breast cancer and about 93 percent (11,882) in those with stage II. The average number of tests performed per patient was 3.7 in the pre- and postoperative periods. Surgeons and oncologists ordered the most tests, with surgeons ordering 74 percent of preoperative tests and oncologists ordering about 41 percent of postoperative tests.

The researchers found that the use of advanced imaging, such as computed tomography, magnetic resonance imaging and positron emission tomography, to investigate possible metastases, has increased and now comprises 41 percent of all initial tests.

There was also variability in use of imaging between geographic regions in the province and between community hospitals and academic institutions.

"If guideline recommendations are to be implemented in practice, additional knowledge translation strategies are needed, as dissemination of clinical practice guidelines alone is not an effective method of changing physician practice behaviors. ... These strategies will also require patient engagement," concluded the authors

In a related commentary, Daniel Rayson, M.D., and Geoff Porter, M.D., of Queen Elizabeth II Health Sciences Centre and Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, wrote, "Both teams [surgical and oncological] may order tests to reassure and support the anxious, newly diagnosed patient and her loved ones - clearly laudable goals. Patients are often blindsided by a cancer diagnosis and rely on their medical team to be as certain as possible that their disease can be cured and they are not dying."

However, testing has a cascading effect, because recommendations for more confirmatory tests, increased wait times for results and possible treatment can heighten patient and family anxiety as well as increase costs and use of healthcare resources.

"It is the responsibility of physicians to be knowledge brokers between the evidence-based guidance and their patients. To do so effectively takes time, energy and good interdisciplinary communication. ... For most patients with newly diagnosed stage I and II breast cancer, reflexively ordering staging investigations does not help relieve stress, nor does it detect disease," stated the commentary authors.

For more information: www.cmaj.ca

Related Content

Partial Breast Irradiation Effective, Convenient Treatment Option for Low-Risk Breast Cancer
News | Radiation Therapy | May 20, 2019
Partial breast irradiation produces similar long-term survival rates and risk for recurrence compared with whole breast...
Managing Architectural Distortion on Mammography Based on MR Enhancement
News | Mammography | May 15, 2019
High negative predictive values (NPV) in mammography architectural distortion (AD) without ultrasonographic (US)...
Screening MRI Detects BI-RADS 3 Breast Cancer in High-risk Patients
News | MRI Breast | May 09, 2019
When appropriate, short-interval follow-up magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can be used to identify early-stage breast...
Novel Artificial Intelligence Method Predicts Future Risk of Breast Cancer
News | Artificial Intelligence | May 08, 2019
Researchers from two major institutions have developed a new tool with advanced artificial intelligence (AI) methods to...
Georgia Becomes 38th State With Breast Density Inform Law
News | Breast Density | May 06, 2019
Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp signed breast density inform bill HB62 into law May 3, 2019. The law, which becomes effective...
American Society of Breast Surgeons Issues Risk-based Screening Mammography Guidelines
News | Mammography | May 03, 2019
The American Society of Breast Surgeons (ASBrS) has released the first screening mammography guidelines based on a...
Hologic Launches Trident HD Specimen Radiography System
Technology | Breast Biopsy Systems | April 26, 2019
Hologic Inc. announced global commercial availability of the Trident HD specimen radiography system. The next-...
California Protons Cancer Therapy Center Begins Breast Cancer Study Enrollment
News | Proton Therapy | April 25, 2019
California Protons Cancer Therapy Center announced two major efforts representing significant steps forward in breast...
Women With Coronary Artery Wall Thickness at Risk for Heart Disease
News | Cardiac Imaging | April 25, 2019
The thickness of the coronary artery wall as measured by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is an independent marker for...
The Cianna Medical Savi Scout Radar Localization system, showing the console, detector and the marker, with a size comparison and X-ray images inside breast tissue. For more information on the learning curve of its use http://sabcs16.posterview.com/nosl/p/P1-11-06.

The Cianna Medical Savi Scout Radar Localization system, showing the console, detector and the marker, with a size comparison and X-ray images inside breast tissue. For more information on the learning curve of its use http://sabcs16.posterview.com/nosl/p/P1-11-06.

Feature | Breast Imaging | April 24, 2019 | By Greg Freiherr
Wires have traditionally been placed prior to lumpectomy to mark cancerous tissues in the breast.