Feature | Information Technology | July 01, 2019 | By Greg Freiherr

Are Shallow Networks Better Than Deep Ones?

“Shallow” learning promises better artificial intelligence, say SIIM presenters

David Anderson at SIIM

David Anderson presents information about the development of artificial Intelligence (AI) at SIIM 2019 as his father, Charles, looks on from a front row seat. The father-son team presented information at the SIIM annual meeting about their use of relatively shallow Deep Learning networks to analyze chest radiographs with AI.

Greg Freiherr

Greg Freiherr

Two simple neural networks are better than one complex one, according to a father-son team of entrepreneurs. On June 27 the two described “A Two-Stage Deep Learning Approach to Chest X-Ray Analysis” during the 2019 meeting of the Society of Imaging Informatics in Medicine in Denver.


Diagnostic decisions coming from models built using two “shallow” neural networks can lead to faster, more accurate and more interpretable artificial intelligence for radiography and other imaging modalities, according to David Anderson.

“When you have a literal deep (learning) network you have lots and lots of computational nodes and lots of layers of those nodes. A shallower network means that there are fewer computations so it is less math going on, which means you can look inside of it and see what it is doing — you can pull it apart,” Anderson told Imaging Technology News after the SIIM presentation.

He and his father, Charles, described their work at SIIM 2019 as a tag team — David presenting technical information first; Charles Anderson following with broader perspectives. Both men work at privately held Pattern Exploration, where Charles Anderson, Ph.D., is CEO; David is the machine learning developer.

David cited research1 & 2 into the automated analysis of chest X-ray images as the basis for the work done at Pattern Exploration. The use of “shallow” networks allows training with unlabelled data, which makes training less difficult and more efficient, he said. The use of these networks can also make the logic underlying AI less opaque.


Making the “Box” Transparent

Many have described deep learning as leading to algorithms that are “black boxes.” If shallower networks are used, however, the result “is not black at all — if you have the right tools,” David Anderson told ITN. “You can say, ‘Here is what this network is doing.’”

The two, five-layer networks that the Andersons developed to model X-ray analysis represent deep learning despite their relatively shallow depth. (Deep learning is a subset of machine learning, which is a type of artificial intelligence.) These two networks have separate tasks. One aligns the images into a standard orientation so the patient spine, for example, is presented vertically. The other does the classification.

Charles, who also serves as a professor of computer science at Colorado State University, focused on the potential impact of the research. He also raised the potential utility of a verbal interface. The computer science professor described during his presentation how such a verbal interface might be used. “It would allow you to ask a quick question — like you do with Siri — and come back with an answer in a spoken language,” he summarized later for ITN.

Supporting verbal Q & A would allow the radiologist to focus on the screen, rather than intermittently shifting attention to input devices. Radiologists have told Charles that their priorities are speed and confidence that their decisions are correct.


Greg Freiherr is a contributing editor to Imaging Technology News (ITN). Over the past three decades, he has served as business and technology editor for publications in medical imaging, as well as consulted for vendors, professional organizations, academia, and financial institutions.


Related content and references:

1. P. Rajpurkar, et al. (2017) CheXNet: Radiologist-Level Pneumonia Detection on Chest X-Rays with Deep Learning. https://arxiv.org/abs/1711.05225v3

2 I. M. Baltruschat, et al. (2018) Comparison of Deep Learning Approaches for Multi-Label Chest X-Ray Classification. https://arxiv.org/abs/1803.02315v1

How AI Might Provide a Safety Net for Patients and Providers

Editor’s note: This article is the ninth piece in a content series by Greg Freiherr covering the Society for Imaging Informatics in Medicine (SIIM) conference in June.


Related content:

How AI Might Provide a Safety Net for Patients and Providers 

Smart Algorithm Extracts Data from Radiology Reports 

PODCAST: Why Blockchain Matters In Medical Imaging

PODCAST: How to Fix Your Enterprise Imaging Network

PODCAST: 5 Low-Cost Ways To Slow Hackers

Cinebot: Efficient Creation of Movies and Animated Gifs for Presentation and Education Directly from PACS

DeepAAA Uses AI to Look Automatically For Aneurysms

Making AI Safe, Effective and Humane for Imaging

Related Content

AIR Recon DL delivers shorter scans and better image quality (Photo: Business Wire)

AIR Recon DL delivers shorter scans and better image quality (Photo: Business Wire).

News | Artificial Intelligence | May 29, 2020
May 29, 2020 — GE Healthcare announced U.S.
The paradox is that COVID-19 has manifested the critical need for exactly what the rules require: advancement of interoperability and digital online access to clinical data and imaging, at scale, for care coordination and infection control.

The paradox is that COVID-19 has manifested the critical need for exactly what the rules require: advancement of interoperability and digital online access to clinical data and imaging, at scale, for care coordination and infection control. Getty Images

Feature | Coronavirus (COVID-19) | May 28, 2020 | By Matthew A. Michela
One year after being proposed, federal rules to advance interoperability in healthcare and create easier access for p
The opportunity to converge the silos of data into a cross-functional analysis can provide immense value during the COVID-19 outbreak and in the future

Getty Images

Feature | Coronavirus (COVID-19) | May 28, 2020 | By Jeff Vachon
In the midst of the coronavirus pandemic normal
United Imaging's uMR OMEGA is designed to provide greater access to magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with the world’s first ultra-wide 75-cm bore 3T MRI.
News | Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) | May 27, 2020
May 27, 2020 — United Imaging's...
In April, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) cleared Intelerad’s InteleConnect EV solution for diagnostic image review on a range of mobile devices.
Feature | PACS | May 27, 2020 | By Melinda Taschetta-Millane
Fast, easily accessible patient images are crucial in this day and age, as imaging and medical records take on a new
Off-site imaging companies are playing a key role in the fight against COVID-19
Feature | Coronavirus (COVID-19) | May 26, 2020 | By Sean Zahniser
After the worst of the COVID-19 pandemic has pas
There were several new developments in digital radiography (DR) technology at the 2019 Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) annual meeting. These trends included integration of artificial intelligence (AI) auto detection technologies, more durable glassless detector plates, and technologies to pull more diagnostic data out of X-ray imaging. Some vendors also have redesigned their DR systems to make them more user-friendly and ergonomic. 
Feature | Digital Radiography (DR) | May 26, 2020 | By Dave Fornell
There were several new developments in digital rad...
 Recently the versatility of mixed and augmented reality products has come to the forefront of the news, with an Imperial led project at the Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust. Doctors have been wearing the Microsoft Hololens headsets whilst working on the front lines of the COVID pandemic, to aid them in their care for their patients. IDTechEx have previously researched this market area in its report “Augmented, Mixed and Virtual Reality 2020-2030: Forecasts, Markets and Technologies”, which predicts th

Doctors wearing the Hololens Device. Source: Imperial.ac.uk

News | Artificial Intelligence | May 22, 2020
May 22, 2020 — Recently the versatility of