News | X-Ray | March 29, 2016

Forensic Researchers Set Standards for X-ray Identification of Bodies

Study compares X-rays of the spine, upper leg and skull to assess ability to determine as well as misclassify individual identities

North Carolina State University study, forensic body identification, X-rays

Forensic researchers have for the first time established science-based standards for identifying human remains based on X-rays of an individual's spine, upper leg (such as the proximal femur image seen here) or the side of the skull. Image courtesy of Ann Ross, North Carolina State University.

March 29, 2016 — Forensic researchers have for the first time established science-based standards for identifying human remains based on X-rays of an individual's spine, upper leg or the side of the skull.

"In the past, forensic experts have relied on a mixed bag of standards when comparing ante-mortem and post-mortem X-rays to establish a positive identification for a body — but previous research has shown that even experts can have trouble making accurate identifications," said Ann Ross, lead author of a paper on the new standards and a professor of anthropology at North Carolina State University.

"We've created a set of standards that will allow for a consistent approach to identification — that can be replicated — and that allows experts to determine probabilities for an identification," Ross said. "For example, you could say with 85 percent certainty that a body is a specific individual."

The researchers compared ante-mortem and post-mortem lateral craniofacial (side of the skull) X-rays for 20 individuals, and did the same for X-rays of the vertebral column (spine) for 50 individuals and X-rays of the proximal femur (upper leg) for 23 individuals. The researchers used these evaluations to develop location-specific standards for each skeletal region. The researchers focused on these skeletal regions because they are among the most frequently X-rayed in a clinical setting.

The researchers then used additional, unmatched X-rays to test the accuracy of the standards in two ways. First, they tested the standards to see how likely they were to accurately identify a body. Second, they ran separate analyses to see how likely the standards were to "misclassify" an identification — to provide a false-positive or false-negative result.

The standards varied significantly.

For example, a side X-ray of the skull could be used to identify a body with 97 percent certainty and a 10 percent misclassification rate based on as few as two specific traits — as long as there were no inconsistencies in the shapes of the skull X-rays. Cervical — or neck — vertebrae performed even better. These could provide greater than 98 percent certainty and a 7 percent misclassification rate based on a single trait.

At the other end of the spectrum, lumbar — or lower back — vertebrae had a 40 percent misclassification rate even if four matching traits were identified.

"Lumbar X-rays can be used to support information from other skeletal locations, but we think they are too unreliable to be used as the primary means of identification," Ross said.

In addition to the location-specific standards, the researchers developed a "decision tree" that forensic experts can use to determine the probability of an ID.

"The goal here is to bring standards and consistency to radiographic ID, and to bring some quantification to the process — so that it's not just based on one expert's individual opinion," Ross said.

"We hope to build on these standards by compiling and evaluating a larger database of post-mortem and ante-mortem X-rays for these and other skeletal structures," Ross added.

The paper, "Establishing Standards for Side-by-Side Radiographic Comparisons," is published online in the American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology. The paper was co-authored by Alicja Lanfear of Middle Tennessee State University and Ashley Maxwell of the University of South Florida. The work was supported by the National Institutes of Justice under grant number 2010-DN-BX-K214.

For more information: www.journals.lww.com

Related Content

Third FDA Clearance Announced for Zebra-Med's AI Solution for Brain Bleed Alerts
Technology | Artificial Intelligence | June 19, 2019
Zebra Medical Vision announced it has received its third U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) 510(k) clearance for...
Canon Medical Receives FDA Clearance for AiCE Reconstruction Technology for CT
Technology | Computed Tomography (CT) | June 18, 2019
Canon Medical Systems USA Inc. has received 510(k) clearance on its new deep convolutional neural network (DCNN) image...
International Working Group Releases New Multiple Myeloma Imaging Guidelines

X-ray images such as the one on the left fail to indicate many cases of advanced bone destruction caused by multiple myeloma, says the author of new guidelines on imaging for patients with myeloma and related disorders. Image courtesy of Roswell Park Comprehensive Cancer Center.

News | Computed Tomography (CT) | June 17, 2019
An International Myeloma Working Group (IMWG) has developed the first set of new recommendations in 10 years for...
A static image drawn from a stack of brain MR images may illustrate the results of a study. But a GIF (or MP4 movie), created by the Cinebot plug-in, can scroll through that stack, providing teaching moments for residents and fellows at Georgetown University

A static image drawn from a stack of brain MR images may illustrate the results of a study. But a GIF (or MP4 movie), created by the Cinebot plug-in, can scroll through that stack, providing teaching moments for residents and fellows at Georgetown University. Image courtesy of MedStar Georgetown University Hospital

Feature | Information Technology | June 13, 2019 | By Greg Freiherr
Editor’s note: This article is the third in a content series by Greg Freiherr covering the Society for Imaging In
Utah Valley Hospital Purchases Nine Carestream Imaging Systems
News | Digital Radiography (DR) | June 12, 2019
Utah Valley Hospital (Provo, Utah) has installed nine Carestream imaging systems that equip its radiology staff to...
Konica Minolta Healthcare Announces Autologous Biologics Workshop in Partnership With EmCyte Corp.
News | Ultrasound Imaging | June 12, 2019
Konica Minolta Healthcare announced a new autologous biologics workshop in partnership with EmCyte Corp. The workshop...
Aidoc Earns FDA Approval for AI for C-spine Fractures
Technology | Artificial Intelligence | June 11, 2019
Radiology artificial intelligence (AI) provider Aidoc announced the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has cleared...
SCCT Announces 2019 Gold Medal Award Recipients
News | Computed Tomography (CT) | June 05, 2019
The Society of Cardiovascular Computed Tomography (SCCT) will present the 2019 Gold Medal Award to Jonathon Leipsic, M....
SIIM and ACR Host Machine Learning Challenge for Pneumothorax Detection and Localization
News | Artificial Intelligence | June 03, 2019
The Society for Imaging Informatics in Medicine (SIIM) and the American College of Radiology (ACR) are collaborating...