Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant
Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant

Greg Freiherr has reported on developments in radiology since 1983. He runs the consulting service, The Freiherr Group.

Blog | Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant | Information Technology| September 28, 2016

Will Smartphones Bring Virtual Reality To Radiology?

virtual reality

Graphic courtesy of Pixabay

If we are to look forward to the development of smartphone technology for radiology applications, we might do well to look at virtual and augmented realities. For decades, radiology has fiddled with these.

The bromance began in the 1980s. It was an infatuation with rudimentary 3-D that progressed a decade later to “data gloves” whose wired sensors translated hand movements into virtual grips, turns and twists of objects.

At an RSNA that now seems a long, long time ago, I (along with many others) was invited into a radiological “CAVE” (CAVE Automatic Virtual Environment) in which I donned a helmet to see the simulated insides of a virtual patient. Those early attempts were updated last year at RSNA when a researcher asserted that smartphone technology could bring VR to mainstream radiology.

A lightweight mobile VR system powered by a high-tech smartphone with an ultra-high-density display can present computed tomography (CT) images stably and at diagnostic quality, according to Vasileios Moustakas, M.D., a radiologist at Evangelismos Hospital in Athens, Greece. Moustakas compared the view with the head-mounted display to being surrounded by a 175-inch mega screen.

 

Next Stop For Smartphones

Smartphones are advancing rapidly into consumer virtual space. Leading the way are Samsung with its Galaxy smartphones complemented by Oculus Rift (Gear VR) technology, and Google, which has sold millions of its Google Cardboard backed by rapidly multiplying apps that can be downloaded on Google Play. These are being followed by efforts within the gaming industry, namely Morpheus from Sony for its PlayStation and Vive from HTC and Valve.

Smartphone technology has taken the early lead in radiology. Moustakas described the ease with which a smartphone system could be applied to the interpretation of images. “Once the files are downloaded it takes less than a minute to wear the VR device and start viewing the CT images,” he said, noting that CT was chosen because the modality is heavily used in emergency departments. “The fact that it’s also mobile is crucial, because this technique can be used for remote diagnosis, avoiding the limitations of the relatively small displays of normal mobile devices.”

A consultant radiologist in the hospital and another radiologist using the VR system remotely reviewed images from 271 CT exams. Their assessments agreed in 97 percent of the cases. “Mobile virtual reality can make it easier for radiologists who want to have access to their examinations, even when they are on the move and away from their workstation,” Moustakas said.

 

Dangers Of Overexuberance

His enthusiasm for the technology, notably, is based on a VR prototype. And getting too excited can lead to disappointment. An example of how high-flying expectations can slow the acceptance of an advanced technology happened in the early 1980s. The capabilities of digital subtraction angiography (DSA) were highly touted in the run-up to the commercial release of the first DSA products. The result was disappointment — and slower adoption of DSA than might otherwise have happened.

If smartphone applications raise expectations too much, might their shortcomings create a diminished perception of the potential of virtual reality in medical imaging?

How VR plays out in radiology may depend on whether smartphones or a more sophisticated core technology leads the radiological charge into the virtual world. A company called Technical Illusions has proven the feasibility of projecting 2-D MR images in three dimensions using augmented reality technology, called castAR, a capability demonstrated in a 35-second clip on YouTube.

The radiological application is just one of many being studied at castAR, which grew from R&D aimed in 2011 at gaming and entertainment. The company today has since broadened its focus to include tech and business but maintains the ambitious goal of making “mixed reality a reality for everyone.”

So which will be widely available first? Will smartphone VR follow more sophisticated systems in much the same way as smartphone displays followed PACS? Or will smartphone-based systems be introduced first?

And, if the latter happens, will limited capabilities define how VR is considered by mainstream radiology? Or will virtual reality using smartphones come with disclaimers, implicit or otherwise, that will keep expectations in check, thus allowing the technology to whet the appetite for more powerful virtual visualization?

They are questions without answers. For now.

Editor's note: This is the fourth blog in a four-part series on smartphones and radiology. The first blog, “How Smartphones Can Make Radiologists Even Smarter,” can be found here. The second blog, “Call Me: How Cell Phones Can Make A Difference in Radiology,” can be found here. The third blog, "Sonographic Smartphones: When Will the Potential Be Met?," can be found here.

 

Related Content

iCAD's ProFound AI Wins Best New Radiology Solution in 2019 MedTech Breakthrough Awards
News | Computer-Aided Detection Software | September 09, 2019
iCAD Inc. announced MedTech Breakthrough, an independent organization that recognizes the top companies and solutions...
A smart algorithm has been trained on a neural network to recognize the appearance of breast cancer in MR images

A smart algorithm has been trained on a neural network to recognize the appearance of breast cancer in MR images. The algorithm, described at the SBI/ACR Breast Imaging Symposium, used deep learning, a form of machine learning, which is a type of artificial intelligence. Image courtesy of Sarah Eskreis-Winkler, M.D.

Feature | Society of Breast Imaging (SBI) | September 06, 2019 | By Greg Freiherr
The use of smart algorithms has the potential to make healthcare more efficient.
Philips and Fujifilm booths at SIIM 2019.

Philips and Fujifilm booths at SIIM 2019.

Feature | SIIM | September 06, 2019 | By Greg Freiherr
Pragmatism from cybersecurity to enterprise imaging was in vogue at the 2019 meeting of the Society of Imaging Inform
Heath information technology diagram showing use of cloud storage.
Feature | Archive Cloud Storage | September 04, 2019 | Tyna Callahan
In healthcare, critical systems are being used to deliver vital information and services 24x7x365.
Global Diagnostics Australia Incorporates AI Into Radiology Applications
News | Artificial Intelligence | September 04, 2019
Global Diagnostics Australia (GDA), a subsidiary of the Integral Diagnostics Group (IDX), has adopted artificial...
The CT scanner might not come with protocols that are adequate for each hospital situation, so at Phoenix Children’s Hospital they designed their own protocols, said Dianna Bardo, M.D., director of body MR and co-director of the 3D Innovation Lab at Phoenix Children’s.

The CT scanner might not come with protocols that are adequate for each hospital situation, so at Phoenix Children’s Hospital they designed their own protocols, said Dianna Bardo, M.D., director of body MR and co-director of the 3D Innovation Lab at Phoenix Children’s.

Sponsored Content | Case Study | Radiation Dose Management | September 04, 2019
Radiation dose management is central to child patient safety. Medical imaging plays an increasing role in the accurate...
Medical Imaging Rates Continue to Rise Despite Push to Reduce Their Use
News | Radiology Imaging | September 03, 2019
Despite a broad campaign among physician groups to reduce the amount of medical imaging, use rates of various scans...
Philips Debuts Cardiac Ultrasound and Enterprise Informatics Offerings at ESC 2019
News | Cardiac Imaging | August 30, 2019
Philips will showcase its latest cardiac care innovations at the European Society of Cardiology (ESC) Congress 2019,...
CIRS Launches Ultrasound Quality Assurance Software
Technology | Quality Assurance (QA) | August 30, 2019
August 30, 2019 — The CIRS Ultrasound...
New Report Reveals Vulnerabilities of Internet of Things-enabled Healthcare Devices
News | Cybersecurity | August 29, 2019
Use of the Internet of Things (IoT) is booming, with IHS Markit forecasting there will be 73 billion connected devices ...