Feature | November 06, 2014 | Greg Freiherr

Digital X-ray and Football: Good, Bad and Ugly

Photo courtesy of Carestream Health

For the most part radiography has been used to help patients. When it comes to football, however, the goal is less to help the athlete and more to get him on the field.

Several years ago the University of Alabama in Birmingham (UAB) cautiously carried a player into the locker room. With his head strapped to the gurney on which he lay, trainers cut off his jersey and shoulder pads, unscrewed the facemask from his helmet, and X-rayed him for what they thought might be a broken neck. When no such injury was found, the player returned to the game, ran a punt back for a touchdown and made a game-saving pick. The UAB director of sports medicine reportedly was so impressed that the university soon installed the NCAA’s first digital X-ray system.

The convoluted logic that led to this outcome is rampant in football today. The National Football League (NFL) has been skewered lately for what amounts to an almost unfathomable lack of sensitivity to personal well-being. The harsh reality of a culture that treats people as objects is apparent in domestic assaults on significant others, as occurred in the case of Ravens’ Ray Rice, and child abuse allegations of the like that haunts the Vikings’ Adrian Peterson.

Football spokespersons would have us think otherwise, but the adoption and use of radiography, particularly in its most advanced form, underscores a culture gone wrong.

At the 2014 NFL Scouting Combine, prospects were evaluated radiographically as part of comprehensive physicals. The exams were described by an administrator at the Indiana University Health Methodist Hospital as “a high volume of chest, orthopedic and other types of X-rays.”

Digital radiography has become all but a necessity in the modern age of football. Several football teams this year jumped into digital radiography, including the Green Bay Packers and San Diego Chargers. They are only the most recent. 

Countless arms, legs, hands and feet are imaged during the course of a season, not to mention a good number of shoulders, ribs, necks and heads. These exams may be necessitated by traumatic blows just delivered in practice or games. Or they may be done to assure staff and players that the pins, plates and brackets, inserted due to previous injuries, are where they are supposed to be. Regardless, the quantity is high.

While the optimal dosing possible with digital X-ray may be mentioned when teams acquire a digital radiography system, it is hard to believe that minimizing radiation dose is a big consideration behind the purchase of these systems.

 Much more likely it is the efficiency of digital X-ray systems that makes them so attractive, specifically their ability to process exposures into images in seconds and beam those images to monitors, even tablets, in the case of the Packers, in the hands of staff on the sidelines during games.

In short, radiography has become a tool for ruling out injury and getting players onto the football field, not on the road to better health. Their use is another and particularly irritating indication that football is in serious need of culture change. 

Greg Freiherr has reported on developments in radiology since 1983. He runs the consulting service, The Freiherr Group. Read more of his views on his blog at www.itnonline.com.

Related Content

Agfa announced the launch of its SmartXR portfolio at RSNA, being held virtually. SmartXR uses a unique combination of hardware and AI-powered software to lighten radiographers’ workloads and provide image acquisition support.
News | Artificial Intelligence | November 29, 2020
November 29, 2020 — Agfa announced the launch of its SmartXR portfolio at...
James P. Borgstede, M.D.

James P. Borgstede, M.D.

News | Radiology Business | November 29, 2020
November 29, 2020 — RSNA President...
During the virtual 106th Scientific Assembly and Annual Meeting of the Radiological Society of North America (RSNA), Nov. 29 to Dec. 5, Siemens Healthineers debuts the MULTIX Impact C,¹ a new ceiling-mounted digital radiography (DR) system.
News | Digital Radiography (DR) | November 29, 2020
November 29, 2020 — During the virtual 106th Scientific Assembly and Annual Meeting of the...
Chest CT images in a 34-year-old man with fever for 4 days. Positive result of reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction assay for severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 using a swab sample was obtained on February 8, 2020. Dates of examination are shown on images. A, Chest CT scan with magnification of lesions in coronal and sagittal planes shows a nodule with reversed halo sign in left lower lobe (box) at the early stage of the pneumonia. B, Chest CT scans in different axial planes and coro

Chest CT images in a 34-year-old man with fever for 4 days. Positive result of reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction assay for severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 using a swab sample was obtained on February 8, 2020. Dates of examination are shown on images. A, Chest CT scan with magnification of lesions in coronal and sagittal planes shows a nodule with reversed halo sign in left lower lobe (box) at the early stage of the pneumonia. B, Chest CT scans in different axial planes and coronal reconstruction show bilateral multifocal ground-glass opacities. The nodular opacity resolved.

News | Coronavirus (COVID-19) | November 29, 2020
November 29, 2020 — The Radiological Society of North America (...
Videos | Remote Viewing Systems | November 28, 2020
Konica Minolta’s theme for RSNA 2020 is Depth of Vision. ITN
Videos | X-Ray | November 28, 2020
Agfa is looking to transform...
Study conducted by medical AI startup Lunit and Massachusetts General Hospital, published in JAMA Network Open - When used as a second reader, the AI algorithm may help detect lung cancer
News | Artificial Intelligence | November 26, 2020
November 26, 2020 — A recent study published in ...
Vital is hosting demonstrations and educational content from industry experts
News | Enterprise Imaging | November 26, 2020
November 26, 2020 — Vital, a Canon Group company, alongside