Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant
Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant

Greg Freiherr has reported on developments in radiology since 1983. He runs the consulting service, The Freiherr Group.

Blog | Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant | Radiology Imaging| July 13, 2016

What To Do About The Draper Effect

value medicine

Image courtesy of Pixabay.

Images shown at trade shows tend to be, well … perfect. The kVP is adjusted precisely in computed tomography (CT); the ultrasound probe is set for optimal penetration and clarity; magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) protocols are tuned like a Stradivarius. Some of the subjects have to border on anorexia, especially the ones used for ultrasound. And, regardless of the modality or the time needed, the data are processed well beyond the average.

And the results show the care taken. They are the radiological expression of what Mad Men fans might call the Don Draper effect — that button-down, crisp white shirt, tie straight and shoes shined to a gloss perfection.

In Seinfeldese, the images are spectacular — but not real. And everyone who’s been around a show floor or two knows it. This raises the question of whether the equipment and the modalities they represent are the best choices for routine cases. It’s a question not easily answered.

 

Draper Images and Value Medicine

What we can say is that Draper images may not work well with value medicine. And that may be a good thing. Nothing undoes a technology or, by extension, a product, like disappointment. And disappointment is sure to happen, if practitioners expect to get these pristine beautiful images when scanning the everyman and everywoman, especially when efficiency and effectiveness are at premiums.

Consider the following: Americans tend to be heavier than the subjects whose innards appear in Draper images. Seldom are techs of the same caliber as the ones that produce those near-perfect images. And the time to process them just isn’t there in a busy workday.

So how do vendors bridge this rift between the way they have traditionally positioned their products and the coming change in the practice of medicine? It won’t be easy. And, more than likely, Draper images will be around for a long time. But their influence might wane.

What could diminish the widespread allure of Draper images at trade shows might be the recognition that practical issues are going to become increasingly important. So, regardless of what companies display at trade shows — regardless of how good the images are on tricked-out machines taking images of ideal subjects with protocols that generate data that are processed to perfection — what will become increasingly important will be what sites can produce under real-life conditions.

What an epiphany it would be for booth visitors to be presented with images produced in a routine setting on real patients (images with patient identification appropriately deleted, of course) by personnel who would typically do the scans. Not the best of the best — not specially trained techs who can turn to a vendor-supplied engineer to produce radiological Renoirs. But realistic presentations that might foster credibility by accurately illustrating the capabilities of a piece of equipment, while at the same time demonstrating the pathologies this equipment might be used to visualize.

 

Auld Lang Syne

Long — long — gone are the days when radiologists could return from a trade show and demand of a hospital administrator the purchase of a specific product. Chief technology officers and other chief executive officers (CXOs) today hold that kind of power. But often CXOs turn to those in the trenches of healthcare when making their decisions.

Faced with realistic illustrations, administrators might see what is possible under real conditions with specific equipment, compare this to what they know and what they need, and return to report their conclusions to the C suite. Might radiologists do the same, influencing not only purchase decisions but, through their relationships with referring physicians and an appreciation for authentic equipment performance, the exams that are ordered?

Admittedly, this might be asking a lot. Draper images are sewn into the fabric of radiology since forever. And they are likely to remain so, especially when high-end systems are shown for the first time. For these new products, which often are tested only selectively, it may be impossible to describe their use in routine conditions, much less obtain images produced under routine conditions.

A Draper-less approach to promotion, however, might be applied to other products in a vendor portfolio, ones that have been around for a while. Trade booths are notoriously tight on space and vendors must pick and choose the equipment they bring to a show. Equipment that does make the cut might be excellent candidates for mini-reality shows — panels bearing still and video images, accompanied by text, that illustrate what different types of equipment can do under realistic circumstances, as well as the people who make those images.

In the years ahead, practical issues are going to determine what sells. Value medicine will impact how equipment is used.

It is all but certain that vendors will continue showing the best images possible, especially to buttress new product launches. But maybe those Draper images could be accompanied by ones made using other equipment, whose performance under everyday conditions can be described and the results shown with images that have real-world value.

Authenticity … what a concept.

 

Editor's note: This is the second blog in a four-part series on patient centricity. The first blog, “Value Medicine: Radiology’s Big Chance,” can be found here.

Related Content

Video Plus Brochure Helps Patients Make Lung Cancer Scan Decision

Image courtesy of the American Thoracic Society

News | Lung Cancer | April 19, 2019
A short video describing the potential benefits and risks of low-dose computed tomography (CT) screening for lung...
FDA Clears GE's Deep Learning Image Reconstruction Engine
Technology | Computed Tomography (CT) | April 19, 2019
GE Healthcare has received 510(k) clearance from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) of its Deep Learning Image...
Artificial Intelligence Performs As Well As Experienced Radiologists in Detecting Prostate Cancer
News | Artificial Intelligence | April 18, 2019
University of California Los Angeles (UCLA) researchers have developed a new artificial intelligence (AI) system to...
A smart algorithm has been trained on a neural network to recognize the appearance of breast cancer in MR images

A smart algorithm has been trained on a neural network to recognize the appearance of breast cancer in MR images. The algorithm, described at the SBI/ACR Breast Imaging Symposium, used “Deep Learning,“ a form of machine learning, which is a type of artificial intelligence. Graphic courtesy of Sarah Eskreis-Winkler, M.D.

Feature | Artificial Intelligence | April 12, 2019 | By Greg Freiherr
The use of smart algorithms has the potential to make healthcare more efficient.
Videos | RSNA | April 03, 2019
ITN Editor Dave Fornell takes a tour of some of the most interesting new medical imaging technologies displa
Four of the top pieces of content in March included news on proton therapy, including a 360 image and videos from ITN's recent visit to the Northwestern Medicine Proton Center in the Chicago suburbs. This image shows the main proton treatment room gantry at the proton center in Warrenville, Ill. Interview with Mark Pankuch, Ph.D.

Four of the top pieces of content in March included news on proton therapy, including a 360 image and videos from ITN's recent visit to the Northwestern Medicine Proton Center in the Chicago suburbs. This image shows the main proton treatment room gantry at the proton center in Warrenville, Ill.
 

Feature | April 02, 2019 | Dave Fornell, Editor and A.J. Connell
April 2, 2019 — Here is the list of the most popular content on the Imaging Technology News (ITN) magazine w
Johns Hopkins Medicine First in U.S. to Install Canon Medical's Aquilion Precision
News | Computed Tomography (CT) | March 26, 2019
March 26, 2019 — Johns Hopkins Medicine now has access to the first...
NIH Study of Brain Energy Patterns Provides New Insights into Alcohol Effects

NIH scientists present a new method for combining measures of brain activity (left) and glucose consumption (right) to study regional specialization and to better understand the effects of alcohol on the human brain. Image courtesy of Ehsan Shokri-Kojori, Ph.D., of NIAAA.

News | Neuro Imaging | March 22, 2019
March 22, 2019 — Assessing the patterns of energy use and neuronal activity simultaneously in the human brain improve