Sean Reilly, ITN Publisher
Sean Reilly, ITN Publisher

Sean Reilly is healthcare brands group publisher (Imaging Technology News and Diagnostic and Interventional Cardiology) at Scranton Gillette Communications.
 

Blog | Sean Reilly, ITN Publisher | January 29, 2015

Where Have All the Cowboys Gone? ITN Publisher Responds to Consumer Reports Article on CT Scanning

The silence is deafening. And since radiology associations, physician groups and vendors have yet to publicly respond to the elephant in the room, I offer the following in hopes we can get the conversation started...

On Tuesday, January 27, Consumer Reports (CR) posted an article and video that, in a not entirely subtle way, accused physicians and the radiology community of ignorance, negligence and/or malfeasance. The gist of CR’s article is that many physicians are sending patients for CT Scans they don’t really need, either to cover a specific part of their anatomy from lawsuits or to pay the mortgages on their pricey CT scanners. And the cherry on top is approximately 15,000 patients receiving CT scans will die from being exposed to high doses of cancer-causing radiation.

Haven’t we danced this dance before?!

The CR piece was, in the very least, irresponsible – igniting yet another media firestorm that will, no doubt, result in unnecessary and unwarranted consumer panic. CR didn’t appear to interview representatives from leading radiology associations, radiology groups or – God forbid – technology vendors for their perspectives on this subject. More disturbing perhaps, one would think the mainstream media would do its homework before parroting Consumer Reports-speak. Not the case. “If it bleeds, it leads baby!”

Nowhere in the article was mention of the number of lives saved by CT scans annually. Nowhere in the article was mention of training programs offered by educational groups, associations, healthcare media, and technology vendors. Nowhere in the article was mention of how said vendors are committing considerable resources to develop transformational dose-lowering technology and dose monitoring software/programs. Might mention of this steal the thunder of CR’s article or subsequent media coverage?

In fairness to Consumer Reports and to healthcare consumers, yes, there have been abuses. Yes, some CT scans have been prescribed for less than altruistic reasons. Yes, more needs to be done to educate healthcare providers about the dangers of radiation dose. Yes, radiation dose is a valid concern that healthcare consumers need to be aware of and discuss with their care providers. My issue is with how this was communicated by both CR and the mainstream media. If you’re going to “educate” – then educate. Don’t sensationalize. Call me loco, but shouldn’t the responsibility of educating healthcare consumers about radiation dose be the responsibility of healthcare professionals, rather than consumer media, who apparently still have much to learn?

Cowboys, let your collective voices be heard. 

 

Radiation Dose Articles and Resources from Imaging Technology News and ITNonline.com

CT Dose: The Need For Management

Comparison Chart: CT Dose Management

Recording and Managing Radiation Dose

Comparison Chart: Radiation Dose Management

White Paper: Utilization of a Dose Management Solution to Lower Radiation in Medical Imaging

White Paper: GE Healthcare's DoseWatch

White Paper: GE Healthcare: Delivering the Right Dose

White Paper: Visualize Your Way to Safer Imaging

Strategies for Low-Dose MDCT

Webinar: Contemporary Adult Cardiac Interventions and Their Associated Radiation Exposure: Managing Dose in an Increasingly Complex Environment

Webinar: Digital Subtraction Angiography With Significantly Reduced Radiation Dose

Pediatric Fluoroscopy Webinar — Important Concepts to Lower Dose

Case Study: University of Washington Medical Center Combines Technique and Technology to Reduce Radiation Dose

Reducing Patient Radiation Dose to Meet the Regulatory Need

UC Davis Papers Advocate New CT Dose Management Strategies

Radiation: Out of Sight, Too Often Out of Mind

Managing Dose: Radiation Exposure on the Rise

Image Wisely Launches New Fluoroscopy Initiative

New Image Wisely Radiation Safety Case on CT Brain Perfusion Now Available

Lifetime Cancer Risk from Heart Imaging Low for Most Children, but Rises with More Complex Tests

Joint Commission Calls for Use of Radiation Dose Monitoring

Houston Healthcare Makes CT Exams Safer With Toshiba’s PROTECT Program, Iterative Reconstruction

Joint Commission Releases Imaging Standards

Putting the Focus on Radiation Dose

Sectra Expands Hospital’s Radiation Dose Tracking Ability

Bayer Launches New Version of Radimetrics Enterprise Platform

Philips Launches DoseWise Portal for Radiation Dose Management

FDA Clears Siemens’ Third-generation Iterative Reconstruction CT Software

Sapheneia and Scannerside Partner to Offer Dose Tracking, Dose Reduction in Radiology

Medic Vision to Showcase Safe CT Enterprise at RSNA 2014

Key Imaging Technology Trends to Watch for at RSNA 2014

Infinitt to Feature Dose M 2.0 Web-based Dose Management Software at RSNA 2014

PACSHealth Announces Dell to Host and Distribute Radiation Dose Monitoring Solution

New KLAS Report Examines Which Dose Monitoring Solutions Providers Are Considering

Related Content

Image Diagnostics Debuting Interventional Radiation Shield at RSNA 2018
News | Radiation Dose Management | October 03, 2018
Image Diagnostics has entered into a product development agreement with ECLS Inc. to design a new radiation shield...
News | Radiation Dose Management | September 24, 2018
AngioDynamics Inc. announced an agreement to acquire RadiaDyne, a privately held medical diagnostic and device company...
Sponsored Content | Whitepapers | Radiation Dose Management | September 10, 2018
It’s crucial for medical professionals to understand the radiation risk/ benefit balance of diagnostic imaging system
The CT scanner might not come with protocols that are adequate for each hospital situation, so at Phoenix Children’s Hospital they designed their own protocols, said Dianna Bardo, M.D., director of body MR and co-director of the 3D Innovation Lab at Phoenix Children’s.

The CT scanner might not come with protocols that are adequate for each hospital situation, so at Phoenix Children’s Hospital they designed their own protocols, said Dianna Bardo, M.D., director of body MR and co-director of the 3D Innovation Lab at Phoenix Children’s.

Sponsored Content | Case Study | Radiation Dose Management | September 07, 2018
Radiation dose management is central to child patient safety. Medical imaging plays an increasing role in the accurate...

Image courtesy of Medic Vision

Feature | Radiation Dose Management | September 06, 2018 | By Mukul Mehra, M.D.
While working with a patient with Crohn’s disease in my gastroenterology practice, I nearly ordered a computed...
Guerbet Partners With Imalogix on Dose Optimization With Artificial Intelligence
News | Radiation Dose Management | August 14, 2018
August 14, 2018 — Guerbet LLC USA announced a commercial partnership with Imalogix, a provider of...
Imalogix Brings Fluoroscopy Capabilities to Radiation Dose Management Platform
Technology | Radiographic Fluoroscopy (RF) | August 06, 2018
Imalogix, a provider of artificial intelligence (AI) process and workflow solutions, announced the availability of the...
Sectra radiation dose monitoring software can help manage radiation dose from multiple medical imaging modalities.
News | Radiation Dose Management | July 25, 2018
July 25, 2018 – Sectra will install its cloud-based,...
The images (before and after) depict a 50 percent dose reduction in chest X-ray without compromising  image quality.

The images (before) depict a 50 percent dose reduction in chest X-ray without compromising
image quality.

Sponsored Content | Case Study | Radiation Dose Management | July 03, 2018
There are a handful of priorities for radiologists: lowest radiation dosage, highest image quality, optimal workflow,...