Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant

Greg Freiherr has reported on developments in radiology since 1983. He runs the consulting service, The Freiherr Group.

Blog | Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant | February 01, 2015

Newt…Take a Lesson from Radiology

We have entered a time in this country when more powerful is not necessarily better, when we can do more than we need to, but to do so is narcissistic nonsense. I was reminded of that by one of this nation’s wannabe leaders, Newt Gingrich, while he was campaigning in Florida before that state’s primary.

An avowed technophile and inveterate politician, Gingrich pledged support for establishing a moon base by the end of his second term as President, noting (one would hope offhandedly) that when the moon's population reaches 13,000, the colony could petition for statehood (Newt's Moon Colony: What Would It Cost? http://www.wmtw.com/r/30331982/detail.html). Anyone familiar with Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia will see the – dare I say it – lunacy of this, but that’s another discussion.

While it may be possible to colonize the moon, an educated electorate asked to pay for a mass exodus of earthlings must ask, “Why?”  just as radiology has been doing for years about equipment that was too expensive for mass consumption. Ironically, the populace of our country has hardly noticed radiology’s common sense, even though it is obvious to anyone who looks. 

Take computed tomography (CT). Demand for multi-slice scanners boomed from the late 1990s. Then, six years ago, demand suddenly dropped. Why? Because leading edge technology no longer provided a broad-based clinical advantage over the earlier generation. There were no heated debates about whether scanners generating 128 or 256+ slices should be purchased. In fact, very little was said. The radiology community just realized the folly of slice wars…and moved on.

In much the same way, sales of new magnetic resonance (MR) units through much of the past decade were flat, despite the mass production of 3T scanners. Why? Because the higher cost of 3T could not be clinically justified. Only lately have the sales of new 3Ts begun to climb to a level even remotely on par with those of 1.5T. And that is only after the price of these 3Ts dropped to levels previously occupied by their one-time premium predecessors at 1.5T. 

Similar scenarios are now or may soon play out in other branches of imaging. The popularity of flat panel X-ray technology rose only after significant drops in price and the introduction of wireless detectors, which allow their cost-effective sharing among instruments, just as computed radiography before it. If the same holds true for positron emission tomography (PET)/CT, with its availability of once premium time-of-flight technologies onboard entry-level scanners, we will see a resurgence in the next few years in the purchase of these products as well.

Clearly, the harsh economics of the past few years have not stopped technological progress, just slowed its spread until the technology met certain value-oriented parameters.

As general purpose radiology roosts on the trailing edge of technology, exotic developments continue to push the boundaries. We have 256+ slice scanners making headway in clinical applications addressing the heart and brain. MR continues to advance at 7T and beyond, just as 3T fills the clinical high ground behind it. PET tests the possibility that quantification will allow better patient assessment and improved management of cancer therapy. But at least until this hypothesis is proven, value-driven PET/CTs — fueled by previously high-end time-of-flight technology — will dominate the marketplace.

In sum, not only has radiology gotten very good at asking why, but also at listening for what it does not want to hear. When the answer lacks substance, the imaging community backs off.

Perhaps if Newt would begin advocating double-digit Tesla because he is “for America being a great country, not a country in decline,” the futility of pursuing imaging technology without a practical purpose would be obvious…and radiology would get the credit it deserves for being smart enough to just say no.

Related Content

Konica Minolta Introduces KDR Primary Digital Radiography System
News | Digital Radiography (DR) | April 20, 2018
Konica Minolta Healthcare Americas Inc. introduced the KDR Primary digital radiography (DR) system at the American...
This image, taken with Canon's Aquilion One, shows a lung with metastases from bowel cancer.

This image, taken with Canon’s Aquilion One, shows a lung with metastases from bowel cancer. Image courtesy of Canon.

Feature | Lung Cancer | April 18, 2018 | Jeff Zagoudis
In recent years, low-dose computed tomography (CT) screening has emerged as a proven, effective method to detect lung
FDA Clears Siemens' Somatom go.All, go.Top CT Scanners
Technology | Computed Tomography (CT) | April 18, 2018
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has cleared the Somatom go.All and Somatom go.Top computed tomography (CT)...
Carestream's Carbon Nano Tube Portable X-ray System Available for Order
News | Digital Radiography (DR) | April 17, 2018
Carestream Health is taking orders for its new Carestream DRX-Revolution Nano Mobile X-ray System in the United States...
Chest X-ray AI Algorithm Correctly Identifies Lung Disease for Dubai Health Authority
Feature | Artificial Intelligence | April 17, 2018
The Dubai Health Authority (DHA) announced the preliminary results of a chest X-ray artificial intelligence (AI)...
Canon Medical Systems' Aquilion Precision CT Receives FDA Clearance
Technology | Computed Tomography (CT) | April 13, 2018
April 13, 2018 — Canon Medical Systems USA Inc. this week received U.S.
Novel PET Agent Could Help Guide Therapy for Brain Diseases

Rat brain 11C‐Me‐NB1 PET images (0‐60 min) superimposed on an MRI template. Credit: SD Krämer et al., ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland

News | PET Imaging | April 10, 2018
Researchers have developed a new imaging agent that could help guide and assess treatments for people with various...
Brainomix Secures $9.8m Investment to Tackle Strokes With AI
News | Stroke | April 05, 2018
April 5, 2018 — Medical imaging company Brainomix has attracted £7m ($9.8 million) of investment to bring its...
FDA Clears Siemens Somatom Edge Plus CT System
Technology | Computed Tomography (CT) | April 04, 2018
April 4, 2018 — The U.S.
Overlay Init