Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant
Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant

Greg Freiherr has reported on developments in radiology since 1983. He runs the consulting service, The Freiherr Group.

Blog | Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant | May 04, 2015

Detectors Versus Tubes: CT Vendors Prepare for Battle

Detectors Versus Tubes: CT Vendors Prepare for Battle

A dual-energy CT shows perfused blood volume in a patient suspected of pulmonary embolism. First proposed 40 years ago, selective energy CT is finally beginning to have a clinical impact through products that either transmit dual-energy CT beams or ones that detect the different energies of photons in a conventional beam.

A battle is taking shape in computed tomography (CT), one that pits the tubes that deliver X-rays against the detectors that record them. It is a fight over how to use X-rays of different energies — variations on the decades-old concept of selective energy CT (SECT), which promise to make diagnoses more accurate and patient management more effective. 

In a sense, it is radiology’s version of the matchup between Blu-ray and HD DVD a decade ago. Vendors are squaring off much like Microsoft and Sony did in 2005 with Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3. And the outcome may be similar. 

On the exhibit floors of trade shows and in presentations by luminaries, CT’s big three are promoting their own brands of SECT. Siemens offers two products, each of which delivers dual-energy CT. One is built around a single X-ray tube, which uses rapid kVp switching technology to alternate the X-ray tube between two distinctive energies. The other has two X-ray tubes, arranged perpendicular to each other, delivering X-rays at different energies.

GE and Philips are proponents of spectral CT. Rather than delivering two X-ray beams at different energies, they have focused on the detector. Their products fire conventional X-ray beams into detectors that record the different energies of photons included in these beams.

Whether one approach is better than the other is anything but clear. Theoretically, said Hugo Bouchard, Ph.D., senior research scientist at the National Physical Laboratory (NPL) in the United Kingdom, the detector-based approach should have an advantage. Spectral imaging, he noted, is not limited to two energies. “But no one has yet shown the benefits of one energy-selective CT method over the other,” he said, “likely because the technologies are too recent.”

Although SECT was proposed in the 1970s, the technology was not commercially available until less than a decade ago, according to Bouchard. The first peer reviewed clinical results were published in 2006. Since then, clinical research has uncovered a range of potential applications.  

Dual-energy and spectral CT may distinguish more effectively than conventional CT tissues of different types, as well as urinary stones of differing chemical composition; enhance stroke evaluation through the improved detection of brain infarcts; help uncover lung cancer lesions by improving contrast-to-noise ratio, overall image quality and tumor delineation; identify calcium-based plaques, even in the presence of iodinated contrast agents; and even reduce artifacts due to beam hardening. Selective energy CT also may, in some instances, reduce radiation dose to patients by reconstructing a “virtual non-contrast CT image” from the contrast-enhanced image by filtering out the iodine in the contrast medium, thereby eliminating the need for a second CT scan. 

Bouchard noted that two energies “could be sufficient for our current clinical needs.” If so, spectral CT and its ability to discriminate photons at several energies would offer only “marginal benefit,” he said. Spectral CT may be limiting itself, in this regard. GE describes its approach as “dual-energy spectral CT,” made possible by its detector using “rapid kV switching to acquire the dual-energy samples.” And Philips uses “dual-energy filters.” 

The means for obtaining the information, therefore, might matter less than the ability to perform selective energy CT. The gaming industry shows how this might happen.

Ten years ago, Sony and Microsoft were locked in battle over Blu-ray and HD DVD.  Blu-ray won. But its victory did not stop Microsoft. Today Xbox One owners can download an app that allows them to play movies on Blu-ray disks, an app that matters less with each passing day as more movies and programs are streamed over the Internet.

The battle over selective energy technologies may be resolved in much the same way. If the concept of SECT proves itself clinically, energy-specific protocols might one day be provided by vendors to suit their machines, which will deliver the goods using whatever means they have handy, much as gaming consoles play movies today.

If so, it will conclude a battle in which everyone, most importantly the patient, wins … a battle that has only begun.

Greg Freiherr has reported on developments in radiology since 1983. He runs the consulting service, The Freiherr Group. Read more of his views on his blog at

Related Content

Example of an intentionally truncated CT image

Figure 1: Example of an intentionally truncated CT image. The truncation percentage was calculated as the ratio of the patient border touching the field of view to the total patient border (red/(read+blue)). Image courtesy of Qaelum.

Feature | Radiation Dose Management | July 15, 2019 | Niki Fitousi, Ph.D., and An Dedulle
One of the main benefits of a radiation dose management system is the possibility to automatically generate alerts when...
Routine scan of abdomen pelvis taken with the UW-Madison’s Revolution 256 CT scanner using the FDA-cleared reconstruction algorithm, called TrueFidelity.

Routine scan of abdomen pelvis taken with the UW-Madison’s Revolution 256 CT scanner using the FDA-cleared reconstruction algorithm, called TrueFidelity. UW-Madison was the first site in the U.S. to get this technology. Its use is now being integrated into UW CT protocols. Image courtesy of Timothy P. Szczykutowicz

Feature | Computed Tomography (CT) | July 12, 2019 | By Greg Freiherr
When providers develop their own imaging protocols, they are wasting time and money, according to...
Mednax National Cardiac Centers of Excellence Program Highlighted at SCCT 2019
News | CT Angiography (CTA) | July 11, 2019
Mednax Inc. and Mednax Radiology Solutions announced that Chief Medical Officer Ricardo C. Cury, M.D., FSCCT, will...
Achenbach to Receive Inaugural 2019 Stephan Achenbach Pioneer Award in Cardiovascular CT
News | Cardiac Imaging | July 10, 2019
The Society of Cardiovascular Computed Tomography (SCCT) will present Stephan Achenbach, M.D., FSCCT with the inaugural...
Researchers Use Artificial Intelligence to Deliver Personalized Radiation Therapy
News | Radiation Therapy | July 09, 2019
New Cleveland Clinic-led research shows that artificial intelligence (AI) can use medical scans and health records to...
Jonathon Leipsic Awarded 2019 DeHaan Award for Innovation in Cardiology
News | Cardiac Imaging | July 08, 2019
Jonathon A. Leipsic, M.D., FSCCT, is the recipient of the 2019 DeHaan Award for Innovation in Cardiology, announced by...
vRad Presents AI Model to Assess Probability of Aortic Dissection
News | Artificial Intelligence | July 01, 2019
vRad (Virtual Radiologic), a Mednax company recently made a scientific presentation, “Screening for Aortic Dissection...
ClariPi Gets FDA Clearance for AI-powered CT Image Denoising Solution
Technology | Computed Tomography (CT) | June 24, 2019
Artificial intelligence (AI) imaging solution form ClariPi Inc. has received U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)...
Third FDA Clearance Announced for Zebra-Med's AI Solution for Brain Bleed Alerts
Technology | Artificial Intelligence | June 19, 2019
Zebra Medical Vision announced it has received its third U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) 510(k) clearance for...
Canon Medical Receives FDA Clearance for AiCE Reconstruction Technology for CT
Technology | Computed Tomography (CT) | June 18, 2019
Canon Medical Systems USA Inc. has received 510(k) clearance on its new deep convolutional neural network (DCNN) image...