Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant
Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant

Greg Freiherr has reported on developments in radiology since 1983. He runs the consulting service, The Freiherr Group.

Blog | Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant | April 20, 2012

'Choosing Wisely' Campaign Validates Use of Imaging Tests

Over the past several years, the radiology community has taken it on the chin with reimbursement cuts to reports of radiation overexposure. Earlier this month, it looked like radiology would be hit again, this time by nine physician societies whose leaders compiled a list of “five things physicians and patients should question” – part of a concerted “Choosing Wisely” campaign launched by organized medicine.

At first glance, it looked gloomy. Of the 45 “things” listed, 26 had to do with imaging. But after examining each group’s recommendations, imaging came out looking pretty good. Rather than attacking radiology, the recommendations were really a vindication that the vast majority of imaging tests are reasonable and justified.

Two groups – the American Society of Nephrology and American Academy of Allergy, Asthma & Immunology – nearly skipped over imaging entirely. Nephrologists named mammography as one of several diagnostic tests (i.e., colonoscopy, prostate-specific antigen and Pap smears) that shouldn’t be performed routinely on dialysis patients with limited life expectancies. Specialists of allergy, asthma and immunology questioned sinus computed tomography (CT) in the same breath as they cautioned against indiscriminately prescribing antibiotics for uncomplicated acute rhinosinusitis.

The American College of Radiology had little choice but to recommend against imaging studies, as these are the only “things” the College addresses. But its choices were in line with long-standing policy, for example, recommending against imaging for uncomplicated headache and against CT for suspected appendicitis, “until ultrasound has been considered”.

Ditto for the American Society of Nuclear Cardiology, whose sole purview is, well…nuclear cardiology. The Society cautioned against the use of imaging for low-risk and asymptomatic patients, as well as for a preoperative assessment of patients facing low- and intermediate-risk noncardiac surgery. Additionally, the Society advised physicians to use methods that reduce radiation exposure or forego tests altogether, “when limited benefits are likely.”

Clinical oncologists advised against performing positron emission tomography (PET), CT and radionuclide bone scans to stage early prostate and breast cancers at low risk for metastasis, just as they cautioned against using these modalities for asymptomatic patients “treated for breast cancer with curative intent.”  

The American Academy of Family Physicians urged caution when imaging for low back pain and against using X-ray absorptiometry to screen for osteoporosis in women under 65 and men under 70 who have no risk factors.

The American College of Physicians mirrored the recommendation of its family practitioner colleagues regarding low back pain, adding three more caveats: recommending against imaging studies as the initial diagnostic test for venous thromboembolism; the use of CT or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to evaluate simple syncope (with a normal neurological exam), and preoperative chest X-rays when intrathoracic pathology is not suspected.

Three of the four cautions raised by cardiologists against imaging questioned stress cardiac imaging and advanced noninvasive imaging for asymptomatic patients or those scheduled to undergo low-risk noncardiac surgery. These were accompanied by advice not to routinely perform echocardiography when following up adults for mild, asymptomatic native valve disease.

Later this year, more specialty groups are expected to issue similar lists. Judging from the nine lists already released, imaging will have reason to be happy.

Related Content

Turkish Hospital Begins MR-Guided Radiation Therapy With Viewray MRIdian Linac
News | Image Guided Radiation Therapy (IGRT) | September 21, 2018
ViewRay Inc. announced that Acibadem Maslak Hospital in Istanbul, Turkey has begun treating patients with ViewRay's...
Philips Showcases Integrated Solutions for Cardiovascular Care at TCT 2018
News | Cardiac Imaging | September 20, 2018
At the Transcatheter Cardiovascular Therapeutics (TCT) annual meeting, Sept. 21–25 in San Diego, Philips is showcasing...
Machine Learning IDs Markers to Help Predict Alzheimer's

Neurologists use structural and diffusion magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to identify changes in brain tissue (both gray and white matter) that are characteristic of Alzheimer's disease and other forms of dementia. The MRI images are analyzed using morphometry and tractography techniques, which detect changes in the shape and dimensions of the brain and in the tissue microstructure, respectively. In this example, the images show the normal brain of an elderly patient. Image courtesy of Jiook Cha.

News | Neuro Imaging | September 20, 2018
New research has shown a combination of two different modes of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), computer-based...
SimonMed Deploys ClearRead CT Enterprise Wide
News | Computer-Aided Detection Software | September 17, 2018
September 17, 2018 — National outpatient physician radiology group SimonMed Imaging has selected Riverain Technologie
Agfa Brings Intelligent Radiography to RSNA 2018
News | Digital Radiography (DR) | September 17, 2018
September 17, 2018 — At the 2018 Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) annual meeting, Nov.
Siemens Healthineers Announces First U.S. Install of Somatom go.Top CT
News | Computed Tomography (CT) | September 17, 2018
September 17, 2018 — The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center in Columbus recently became the first healthcare
Ingenia Ambition X 1.5T MR. This innovation is the latest advance in the Ingenia MRI portfolio, which comprises fully-digital MRI systems, healthcare informatics and a range of maintenance and life cycle services for integrated solutions that empower a faster, smarter, and simpler path to enabling a confident diagnosis
News | Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) | September 14, 2018
Philips, a global leader in health technology, launched the Ingenia Ambition X 1.5T MR.
At RSNA 2018, radiology professionals will discover intelligent radiography powered by MUSICA, at Agfa's booth.

At RSNA 2018, radiology professionals will discover intelligent radiography powered by MUSICA, at Agfa's booth.

News | Digital Radiography (DR) | September 13, 2018
At RSNA 2018, radiology professionals will discover intelligent
breast screening
News | Clinical Trials | September 13, 2018
Fewer and fewer women die from breast cancer in recent years but, surprisingly, the decline is just as large in the a