Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant

Greg Freiherr has reported on developments in radiology since 1983. He runs the consulting service, The Freiherr Group.

Blog | Greg Freiherr, Industry Consultant | January 20, 2012

X-ray’s Long Courtship With Solid-State Detectors

Fifteen years ago, I was ready to bet the farm that X-ray, with its hundreds of thousands of systems installed worldwide, was ready to embrace the digital revolution. Every other modality had done so. PACS gurus lamented that X-ray’s intransigence was the main – if not the only – reason that PACS was not catching on. And their argument made sense. Radiographs alone accounted for about 70% of all radiologic images. Major suppliers, including Thales in Europe and Varian on this side of the Atlantic, had announced fabrication facilities capable of stoking the digital fire.

It was easy to conclude, therefore, that digital X-ray was a freight train on a radiological turntable ready to synch up with the rest of modern imaging. But it wasn’t…and it didn’t…at least, not the way I thought it would.

Rather than shiny new X-ray systems arriving on the loading docks of hospitals across America, computed radiography surged. Money made the difference. Flat panel detectors were just too expensive. In place of the digital X-ray revolution arose a plaintive “yes, but…” discourse that now, finally, may be at an end.

Flat panels have invaded the last bastion of radiography – mobile X-ray – with decreasing cost and increasing ease. Wireless technology is championing both.

At RSNA 2011, the big names in radiography were pitching wireless as the cornerstone for sharing detectors and, thereby, reducing capital equipment costs for going digital. By transmitting data wirelessly from detector to acquisition console, flat panels can be shared from table to upright chest stand and from radiography suite to the portables that image bedridden patients.

No system exemplifies this potential better than Fujfilm Medical Systems USA’s new FDR Go flex. When this system clears the FDA – it was shown as a work-in-progress at the RSNA meeting – owners of analog systems will be able to transition to digital through a simple three-step process. First, an electronics box will be placed into the cassette drawer of the radiography table, upright or mobile X-ray. Second, a specially designed laptop will be mounted on the analog system to acquire and process the data. Third, the newly digitalized system will be configured to connect with the company’s wireless D-EVO flat panel detector and the facility’s IT network.

Other vendors offer similar upgrade paths, each designed to make the transition from analog to digital as painless as possible, allowing facilities to change out as many analog platforms as they want over whatever time period makes financial sense.

Clearly, the long-awaited digital revolution in X-ray is at hand. It will have taken hold, when aging radiography suites and mobile X-ray units are finally scrapped in favor of products designed specifically for digital detectors…but this will happen decades later than I would have expected.

Related Content

News | Clinical Decision Support | October 27, 2016
October 27, 2016 — The National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN) continues to build its library of appropriate use
Check-Cap, colorectal cancer screening capsule, ACG, UEGW, clinical data, colorectal cancer screening
News | Colonoscopy Systems | October 27, 2016
Check-Cap Ltd. announced additional clinical data was recently presented on its ingestible capsule for preparation-free...
Technology | Orthopedic Imaging | October 27, 2016
At the 2016 North American Society Spine Meeting (NASS), DePuy Synthes Spine showcased the Kick System with...
SLAC, blank X-ray, Joachim Stohr

An illustration shows what happens in a typical experiment with SLAC’s LCLS X-ray laser, top, versus what happened in this study with an especially intense X-ray pulse. Normally the X-ray pulses -- which are shown coming in from the right -- scatter off electrons in a sample and produce a pattern in a detector. But when researchers cranked up the intensity of the X-ray pulses, the pulses seemed to go straight through the sample, as if it were not there, and the pattern in the detector vanished. Two recent papers describe and explain this surprising result, which is due to a ‘nonlinear’ effect where particles of X-ray light team up to cause unexpected things to happen. Image courtesy of SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory.

News | X-Ray | October 27, 2016
Imagine getting a medical X-ray that comes out blank – as if your bones had vanished. That’s what happened when...
pediatric imaging, chest radiography, mistakes, errors, tips, American Journal of Roentgenology
News | Pediatric Imaging | October 26, 2016
While radiography remains the gold standard in pediatric imaging, it is rife with opportunities for error because...
RSNA 2016, RSNA FastPass, RSNA products, RSNA Expo, RSNA exhibits, RSNA show floor, RSNA vendors
News | RSNA 2016 | October 26, 2016
To help readers find the specific technology they are looking for out of the 700 vendors on the vast expo floor at th
Technology | Digital Radiography (DR) | October 26, 2016
Utah-based healthcare technology company Novarad will be exhibiting its ChameleonDR digital radiography solution at the...
Case Western Reserve University study, machine learning, MRI, brain cancer diagnoses, radiomics

MRI scans of patients with radiation necrosis (above) and cancer recurrence (below) are shown in the left column. Close-ups in the center column show the regions are indistinguishable on routine scans. Radiomic descriptors unearth subtle differences showing radiation necrosis, in the upper right panel, has less heterogeneity, shown in blue, compared to cancer recurrence, in the lower right, which has a much higher degree of heterogeneity, shown in red. Credit: Pallavi Tiwari

News | Analytics Software | October 25, 2016
Computer programs have defeated humans in Jeopardy!, chess and Go. Now a program developed at Case Western Reserve...
News | Imaging | October 24, 2016
Strategic Radiology (SR) has committed $800,000 to fund 20 Strategic Radiology Research Seed Grants through the...
Swissray, DDRAura OTC, APS, digital X-ray system, RSNA 2016
Technology | Digital Radiography (DR) | October 24, 2016
Swissray received U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval earlier in 2016 for the ddRAura OTC digital X-ray...
Overlay Init